I have almost the exact same feelings. I had a 5 16gb, ran out of memory, so had no choice but to get a new phone. I didn't want a 6 because of the size and design, but did so for the memory. The 6's design is just missing something. It's not an ugly phone, but doesn't make you say WOW like the previous versions. The 6 looks is just regular looking. Add to that the bigger size making it harder for 1-handed use and the unnerving feeling that I'm going to drop the phone, I recently traded my 6 and got back into a 5s. Looking back, when I sold my 5, I should have moved into a 5s and not a 6.