1. SeanHRCC's Avatar
    Take the apple tv and pretend it only streams music, now compare it feature to feature to the blackberry how does the blackberry win? How are you guys gonna run this in your car easily? it has to be powered so now you have an inverter to plug in, the device plugged into the inverter then a cord from this to your dash seems like a mess why not just run one cord to your dash from the phone or better yet buy a new car or radio that has wireless streaming?
    Pretend that the Apple TV only streams music? Then it's even more over priced for $100 than it is right now.

    This product is perfectly relevant to this apple related website because of its functionality with the iPhone/iPod Touch/iPad.

    And let's start getting technical here...most of your MP3's are not going to take advantage of an optical connection, because most MP3's are compressed garbage. Only recently has Apple begun offering loss less music through iTunes (and it's not even true loss less), and most of our libraries of MP3's consist of audio files that are many times even lesser than the basic offerings from iTunes/Amazon/Etc...the fact of the matter is, digital music for the most part is not going to have a need for a high end audio system...and most consumers would be perfectly content with the analog setup this BB Gateway provides.

    You keep approaching this as if the review some how placed this product above ALL products when it comes to audio connections...to be perfectly honest with you, most consumers would be content with THIS (and it's like $3)...



    ...that said, you're an ***** if you buy an Apple TV to stream music in your house.
    08-13-2012 04:35 PM
  2. Turbo_lemon's Avatar
    Pretend that the Apple TV only streams music? Then it's even more over priced for $100 than it is right now.

    This product is perfectly relevant to this apple related website because of its functionality with the iPhone/iPod Touch/iPad.

    And let's start getting technical here...most of your MP3's are not going to take advantage of an optical connection, because most MP3's are compressed garbage. Only recently has Apple begun offering loss less music through iTunes (and it's not even true loss less), and most of our libraries of MP3's consist of audio files that are many times even lesser than the basic offerings from iTunes/Amazon/Etc...the fact of the matter is, digital music for the most part is not going to have a need for a high end audio system...and most consumers would be perfectly content with the analog setup this BB Gateway provides.

    You keep approaching this as if the review some how placed this product above ALL products when it comes to audio connections...to be perfectly honest with you, most consumers would be content with THIS (and it's like $3)...

    Click to view quoted image


    ...that said, you're an ***** if you buy an Apple TV to stream music in your house.
    Where did I say I bought an apple tv for just streaming music? I said if you take the apple tv and only compare the audio streaming capabilities to the blackberry how does the blackberry win? Answer is it simply doesnt and you are right most people wont need or buy this as a cable is cheaper and gives you the same crappy analog sound. You dont know me and have never been to my home to see my audio set up so your idea that I have no clue what I am talking about is complete arrogance and wrong.
    08-13-2012 04:52 PM
  3. SeanHRCC's Avatar
    Where did I say I bought an apple tv for just streaming music? I said if you take the apple tv and only compare the audio streaming capabilities to the blackberry how does the blackberry win? Answer is it simply doesnt and you are right most people wont need or buy this as a cable is cheaper and gives you the same crappy analog sound. You dont know me and have never been to my home to see my audio set up so your idea that I have no clue what I am talking about is complete arrogance and wrong.
    I never said YOU bought an Apple TV sweetheart...go back and read my post, i said "you're an ***** if you buy an Apple TV to stream music in your house.", that is a general, blanket statement...in no way was it directed at you or any one person, it was a comment that envelopes ALL people who would do that.

    My basis for saying you haven't a clue what you're talking about stems from your initial idea (based on your own comments) that the Apple TV was a high end audio-phile option to what this BB Gateway does (which it is not)...then your comment implying that record players are some how substandard audio sources (i actually laughed at that one)...the icing on the cake was the fact that you are so passionate that your compressed, low quality MP3's desperately need high end audio equipment to be enjoyed. Roll that all up in a neat little ball and yes, i can paint a pretty accurate picture that you're clueless in your own argument. There's no arrogance about it, you spelled it all out for us...and it certainly isn't wrong at all.

    Just walk away from the convo bud. You're passionately arguing a very moot point, and you're discussion became illegitimate when you tried to compare this product to the Apple TV saying the prices were negligible between the two.
    kch50428 likes this.
    08-13-2012 05:53 PM
  4. Turbo_lemon's Avatar
    You guys are just way too advanced actually retarded, it is a relevant term to use here as you seem to be stuck in 1960's. Keep on running your antique record players and 2 channel sound gramps maybe you oughta trade in your iphone for a rotary dial too! For my money and for anyone that actually wants multi channel digital sound - ya know the kind everyone 99% of people use these days, the blackberry music gateway is garbage. I stick to my argument that for the extra $59 you get way better quality audio, a whole slew of additional features and functionality and that there is no good reason to buy the blackberry over it.
    Last edited by Turbo_lemon; 08-13-2012 at 10:05 PM.
    08-13-2012 09:55 PM
  5. kch50428's Avatar
    You guys are just way too advanced actually retarded, it is a relevant term to use here as you seem to be stuck in 1960's. Keep on running your antique record players and 2 channel sound gramps maybe you oughta trade in your iphone for a rotary dial too! For my money and for anyone that actually wants multi channel digital sound - ya know the kind everyone 99% of people use these days, the blackberry music gateway is garbage. I stick to my argument that for the extra $59 you get way better quality audio, a whole slew of additional features and functionality and that there is no good reason to buy the blackberry over it.
    now you've resorted to trolling. way to go. PEBCAK.
    08-13-2012 10:15 PM
  6. Sharma15's Avatar
    Man am I the ONLY one that comes to imore to read about the latest APPLE tech and news?? I expect there to be an emphasis on apple products over competing products unless there is some feature the competition is better at and with this review its obvious the apple tv is a better product and I get **** on for pointing it out.
    Who died and made you queen? This is iMore, changed from TiPB because this blog is more than just iPhone. Its apart of mobile nations, which included CrackBerry, Windows Phone Central, Android Central, and WEB OS Nation. So what if iMore posted a review about a Blackberry product, big f***ken deal! You don't like it? Dont read it. You want emphasis? When the iPhone 4S came out there must have been a giant blog post at least every day about the look, design, user ability, features, and this went on for like a month! When iOS 6 dropped the same thing happened. I don't see any posts about new BlackBerry's or Android phones here, but there are many accessories that are compatible with those devices and they are talked about and reviewed here.

    Comparing the 2 devices, I don't see ANY use for the Apple TV compared to the BlackBerry Music Gateway.

    1) Its cheaper. If 50 bucks mean nothing to you I will give you my PayPal account and transfer the money there. I promise to put it to good use.

    2) All (if not most) TV's come with built in apps for YouTube, Netflix, etc that allow you to stream content to your TV for no extra charge and no additional hardware required. Yea, you wont have iTunes but I'm not willing to spend $100 bucks to get music streamed when I can just get a cheap AUX cord and plug it into my device.

    3) You talk about quality? How is HDMI quality? HDMI cables are marketed differently with "120 Hz" or "240Hz" but they are all the same. You can go to your nearest dollar store pick up a HDMI cable and buy the most top-of-the-line HDMI cable from any store, (You might want to sit down for this), and you get the EXACT.SAME.QUALITY.PICTURE. There is no difference in sound quality and no one uses HDMI to stream music only. You can purchase any cheap car adapter for the B.M.G. and use it in your car easy, try it with the Apple TV.

    4) Also, you missed a very simple detail: The BlackBerry Music Gateway is designed for MUSIC content, whereas the AppleTV is designed for TV content. This discussion should really just stop here but I'm on a roll here.

    5) The BlackBerry Music Gateway is compatible with almost any current media system with the AUX 3.5mm connector and with it's bluetooth connectivity it can easily connect to any smartphone on the market, pretty appealing to the majority user group. Not to mention the fact that you can have multiple devices connected to it, allowing your friends to play their songs and become the DJ's.Heck, it even works with NFC, and we all know that you read that article a wile back about how "Apple was going to pioneer NFC to the world" and what not.

    6) Not everyone has iTunes (I have an iPhone and I don't even LIKE using iTunes, ****tiest piece of software for PC ever) and not everyone want's iTunes. The BlackBerry Music Gateway can basically connect to any Bluetooth device, like my laptop, and steam music to an entertainment system using any music playing program, like windows media player or even VLC for that matter.

    7) You mentioned quality a lot. Let's talk about Apple quality. It's all made in china under some of the worst working conditions in modern times, and it's obsolete on release when TV's come built in with the very features your paying for. Sure, you get a nice apple warranty, but don't you ever wonder why they offer you such a nice deal? Maybe because it's soo cheap to manufacture that in case something does go wrong and there needs to be a replacement (and trust me, there always is) it's just pennies out of apples pockets?

    You want to have an opinion, be able to back it up with logical facts. BS alone can't save you here. Calling something inferior because you don't like it is ignorant.
    08-14-2012 01:27 AM
  7. pkcable's Avatar
    Just for the record, Apple TV has received plenty of coverage over the years here.....

    Apple TV | iMore.com



    EDIT: Why do people have to be so polarized over platform choice? You know some of us appreciate all the platforms. I have a BB Phone & Tablet, an Android Tablet and an iOS ipod Touch. Plus I have owned Android phones and OTHER android tablets in the past also in addition to my current Nexus 7. And for my next phone I still have not ruled out the iphone 5, but I will honestly say I am leaning towards the BB10, BUT the iphone WILL get serious consideration, especially if BB10 gets delayed again.
    Last edited by pkcable; 08-14-2012 at 09:40 AM.
    08-14-2012 09:32 AM
  8. SeanHRCC's Avatar
    You guys are just way too advanced actually retarded, it is a relevant term to use here as you seem to be stuck in 1960's. Keep on running your antique record players and 2 channel sound gramps maybe you oughta trade in your iphone for a rotary dial too! For my money and for anyone that actually wants multi channel digital sound - ya know the kind everyone 99% of people use these days, the blackberry music gateway is garbage. I stick to my argument that for the extra $59 you get way better quality audio, a whole slew of additional features and functionality and that there is no good reason to buy the blackberry over it.
    Aww kiddo, now you just sound like a blathering ***** (not that your earlier retorts were much different to be honest). Admit a few things to yourself...

    - You know **** all about audio equipment
    - You made this thread and realized early on that your argument was pretty asinine
    - You now must resort to personal shots (IE: calling us retarded) because you still have no point

    ...the bottom line is this, sure...the Apple TV does more than the BB Gateway in the same way that a speed boat does more than a canoe. In the end, your point was made, you would rather spend twice as much money on the Apple TV because you want a multi-channel source for your MP3 library and you don't think the BB Gateway is worth it...we get it, you're an Apple TV fan, congratulations, you are a winner.

    Putting aside that, you should really step back and do some research before you waste money on the Apple TV if this multi-channel audio is so important to you, there are other (See: Better) options out there that you could be using...and had you found these things, you wouldn't seem like such a dolt trying to scream to the masses how amazing the Apple TV is.

    Good luck to you little one.
    Sharma15 likes this.
    08-14-2012 11:12 AM
33 12
LINK TO POST COPIED TO CLIPBOARD