Life goes on...
I'm ready for a JB! I'm still on Spirit 3.1.3. I love my qTweeter, Google Voice, Winterboard, etc. You get the idea. I know there are compatible apps to qTweeter that don't require JB, I can use the GV webapp, and now Apple lets me use custom a wallpaper in 4.0. Fine.
But what about custom tones for Calendar, SMS, email...?
jglow74 puts it pretty well. As long as Apple is more interested in stopping j/b'ing than in why its customers would like to j/b in the first place, we will continue to j/b.
For all it's technological beauty and functionality, the iPhone can be even better, more functional and, yes, more more beautiful. Apple prefers the "one size fits all." They were not, at first, too eager to allow third-party apps, until they saw how much money they could make!
Why can't Apple allow the same functionality that can be found through jailbreaking? Even when they seem to, like with the "multi-tasking" to be had in 4.0, it's sub-par. The Apple m/t mode is not as useful and as powerful as "Backgrounder."
Why can't Apple give us the ability to have user "profiles" on the phone, to read our calendars and silence the phone for meetings or at bedtime?
Why can't we get intelligent "lock screens" and see the weather and news headlines when we first bring up the screen?
Why can't we have five by five icon screens, if we want them? (The iPad at even four by five icons is a lot of wasted space!)
The list goes on and on....
These functions are not rocket science and won't break the phone--only enhance it.
So, for many people, j/b will continue as long as possible. For most of us, it's not being a "rebel" or the desire to slap Steve Jobs in the face. It's a compliment to his talent, and like the child you bring into the world, you want that child to grow and find their role in life, to meet their true potential, and not be hovered over and locked away. Otherwise you risk raising a really dysfunctional creature.
Oh, and for GeoHort. He was a pioneer and a cleaver one, but there are others ready to take up the challenge... and they will.
Michael in Maine