1. rebretz000's Avatar
    The iPhone Xs is the first iPhone have I used. Prior to this year I have been exclusively using Android smartphones, mainly Motorola and then Google brands. The following are just some random thoughts of a review.

    Google Assistant vs Siri
    I’m calling this a tie even though all reviewers including MKBHD say Google Assistant is better. Yes Google Assistant is better. It could answer how many season The Big Bang Theory has been on the air and Siri couldn’t but Siri has been more reliable for me in mundane tasks than Google Assistant was. With Siri when I say to call someone it has yet to fail. Sometime with Google Assistant it would just bring up the person contact card but not make the call.

    Android Win
    The notification system on Android is setup better than on iOS in my opinion. When a new email or text comes in only the section of pixels needed to light up the icon on the screen lights up and not the icon and entire screen. It’s a small thing but I think it would help battery life also. The whole screen may light on iOS because there is such a small number of phones with OLED screens and iOS hasn’t been updated to take advantage of the screen yet. Something else on Android I like better is the command center. You can long press the Wi-Fi icon to quickly change the network you are connected to instead of having to go through settings to find Wi-Fi and make the change. It may be that I have figured it out yet but I Google’s photo app is better than Apple’s version. Google’s photos app separates different photos into folders, like camera pictures, downloaded, screenshots all get their own folders in the app but so far in the photo app on the iPhone everything is just in one location. Again it may be that I haven’t figured out that app yet. I also like having an app drawer on Android. My own home screen was virtually blank with only a few icons with all my other apps just in the app drawer. I also really liked being able to arrange my icons/apps where I wanted on my home screen. On iOS obviously there is no app drawer, all app/icons are on the home screen or home screens and you can’t move the apps around. They have to line up one right after another. You can see an example of what I mean in the pictures I add. You can also change the launcher on Android and theme it and change the icon packs. With Android you can also sideload apps without having to unlock/root or jailbreak your phone. I also prefer Google's Keyboard as it mimics a laptop keyboard more, at least a PC keyboard.

    iPhone Win
    On the other side I will start with iMessage, do I even need to say anything? Apple’s gestures on the new iPhones are way better than Android’s gestures or the three button navigation on the Pixel phones. It took me no time get used to Apple’s gestures. It seems more natural and intuitive to use. Google’s gestures they are pushing seem half baked and rushed. To me the iPhone Xs is a much better design than the Pixel phones. Last year when the iPhone X was released I couldn’t stand the notch and thought it was ugly and worthless but it has grown on me over the past year. It apparently grew on most of the Android manufactures also as most copied the design but without all the goodies that Apple crammed into theirs. Talking about notches brings me to my next two Apple wins. First I will talk about Face ID over fingerprint sensor. Overall I will choose Face ID over the fingerprint sensor. I personally had issues with the fingerprint sensor on my Pixel phones over the last two years. I’d say I had about 20% failure rate but I have not had any issues, well maybe one here and there, with Face ID. Seems like my main problems are first thing in the morning when it is still dark. Second topic that goes with the notch and overall design is front facing speakers. A good number of my Android phones have had dual front facing speakers. I was a little apprehensive about losing those when I switch to the iPhone but I really like the speakers on the iPhone. I really do think they are on par with, maybe even better than the speakers on my Pixel 2. Hardware in general. Apple’s SOC are way more advanced that Qualcomm and if rumors of Apple working on their own modems are correct than I know theirs will be better also. Bluetooth also works better on the iPhone that the last two Pixel phones I’ve had. Apps on iOS seems to function better than on Android. Also I love the App icon uniformity that iOS has that Google and Android has never been able to get. I think both of the iOS app advantages have to do with ecosystem.
    Finally even though Android has a more robust ecosystem I think Apple’s ecosystem, even though I am not in it yet, is by far the better ecosystem. Apple is the only manufacture putting out an iOS device which is why I think apps look and function better.

    I am glad I made the switch and have no regrets. I plan on getting a MacBook in the future and I have an Apple watch ordered already. I don't know if one phone is better than the other but for me right now I am preferring the iPhone.

    Below are picture examples of the homescreen setups of my previous Android phones.
    Attached Thumbnails iPhone Xs from an Android users perspective-screenshot_20151228-103238.jpg   iPhone Xs from an Android users perspective-screenshot_20160925-181903.png   iPhone Xs from an Android users perspective-screenshot_20170407-071648.png   iPhone Xs from an Android users perspective-screenshot_20180911-133008.jpg  
    Last edited by rebretz000; 10-16-2018 at 10:57 AM.
    10-16-2018 09:52 AM
  2. Lee_Bo's Avatar
    I also came from exclusively Android devices prior to April 2016. While I loved, and still love, the customization of Android, I love the reliability of Apple. The cost, not so much. :-)
    aximtreo, tadpoles and mumfoau like this.
    10-16-2018 10:51 AM
  3. Quis89's Avatar
    Thanks for the summary! Hope you enjoy your new device.
    10-16-2018 12:46 PM
  4. popkurn611's Avatar
    Awesome review! Once you get deeper into the ecosystem, you will realize how well it all works and how difficult it is to leave. I've tried to leave countless times and always run back. There are pros and cons of each platform and the ecosystem and apple watch are the main reasons I come back. I wish we can have our cake and eat it too...some added customization and an even better notification system with iOS are on my wishlist.

    Btw, nice Rey background on the android! Below is my apple watch background.

    rebretz000 and Westiemom like this.
    10-16-2018 02:08 PM
  5. kataran's Avatar
    Nice Read
    10-16-2018 02:24 PM
  6. bakron1's Avatar
    Nice read and I have also spent a lot of tine on Android, Windows Mobile and Blackberry OS. While they all had good features which made each one unique, I like the simplicity of IOS and the fact it just works.
    10-16-2018 07:25 PM
  7. flyinion's Avatar
    Welcome to the "dark side" I used to use Android exclusively as well until 2015 when the 6s/6s+ came out. I switched after having continuously heard how apps were more polished/etc. on iOS and also I saw the iPhone event in Sept. 2015 and the 3D touch thing really had me intrigued. It was like Android's "long press" but different. 3 years later I'm still on iOS I think probably the biggest thing I miss is the homescreen customization. Not just layout but the custom icon packs as well.
    10-17-2018 05:37 PM
  8. Just_Me_D's Avatar
    Thank you for sharing your personal views of your new iPhone XS with us. Have a great day...
    10-17-2018 06:31 PM
  9. TripleOne's Avatar
    Great review. It was very fun to read!
    mumfoau likes this.
    10-17-2018 06:31 PM
  10. MaxSmarties's Avatar
    It is not easy to switch from android to iOS and be satisfied as it is. It usually takes time.
    10-20-2018 03:11 PM
  11. Westiemom's Avatar
    Welcome to the “Dark Side” OP. Lol! I too came from Android and I concur with your review, spot on!
    I miss some things, but not enough to make me go back. I love Apple and all my Apple things. They just work well and are consistently useful and reliable.
    And you’re gonna love the watch!!
    rebretz000 likes this.
    10-22-2018 10:07 AM
  12. chezm's Avatar
    Current phone is 7+, have a Pixel 3(not xl) preordered and wondering if I’m making a mistake going back to android. The one thing I can’t agree with you mentioned is Siri and Google assistant on par, Siri is so much worse than GA and after 2 years of using Siri this was one thing I was really excited to use on android natively.

    With that said I think in general iOS is very solid, simple OS I don’t need to worry about it performing as it mostly works. I am tempted by android being more like iOS with android but all the raised issues of the pixel have me already considering to return in time period and get an XS
    10-28-2018 10:07 PM

Similar Threads

  1. Replies: 5
    Last Post: 10-19-2018, 06:59 PM
  2. My iPhone won't leave the restart screen
    By iMore Question in forum Ask a Question
    Replies: 6
    Last Post: 10-17-2018, 09:20 AM
  3. Don't let your iPhone XR slip with these heavy duty cases
    By iMore.com in forum iMore.com News Discussion
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 10-16-2018, 08:10 AM
  4. [REVIEW] Griffin Survivor Strong for the iPhone XS Max
    By DecAway in forum iPhone XS Max
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 10-15-2018, 10:24 PM
LINK TO POST COPIED TO CLIPBOARD