I have been very dissatisfied with all 3rd party cases this year. I quickly returned my PEEL case, which had a "dime store" quality to it. I get the feeling every time they sell one, they laugh, call the buyer a sucker and count the $$$.
I waited a long time for the Moshi iGlaze case in Merlot, and it finally came and I can't believe I spent $35 on that case, it felt cheap and it was slippery. Waste of $$$.
I went overboard and ordered a KERF custom leather and steel case for $154 and it came in with defects and gaps in the leather and the metal was bowed out. They talk about the care and effort put into the perfection of every custom made case. Waited about 10-days to ship and I had to return it for repairs or for them to redo the case.
I keep going back to the Apple (Product Red) Leather and Silicone cases. I am considering trying the Vaja Leather or get another Sena Leather case, the black with the red stripe. I have always like Sena and maybe the Vaja is worth a try.
Just sad about "case quality" this year.. it's like the phoning it in.