[msm0511]

So Apple just released their 2nd quarter results, and Tim Cook said that the X was the best selling iPhone every week in the March quarter. So much for it being a flop as so many like to say.

[bakron1]

So Apple just released their 2nd quarter results, and Tim Cook said that the X was the best selling iPhone every week in the March quarter. So much for it being a flop as so many like to say.

Great news all the way around, thanks for sharing.

[Just_Me_D]

Unfortunately, the good news still won't stop the naysayers and haters from claiming otherwise.

[Frehley]

Unfortunately, the good news still won't stop the naysayers and haters from claiming otherwise.

Yep, you got that right...can't wait to see what the "analysts" post tomorrow.

[Mr Segundus]

I agree that the X isn't a flop. But it wasn't that hard for me to get one on release day. I didn't preorder one and I walked into a Best Buy and purchased a 256GB X like four hours after the store opened.

[Annie_8plus]

Unfortunately, the good news still won't stop the naysayers and haters from claiming otherwise.

I’m sure of that!

[Garz]

Blame the so called experts. Or maybe they are just trying to create page hits.

[eyesopen1111]

Blame the so called experts. Or maybe they are just trying to create page hits.

This.

[Lee_Bo]

Are the actual numbers available? Selling 1 can make something a best selling item.

Not being negative, just being realistic.

[doogald]

Are the actual numbers available? Selling 1 can make something a best selling item.

Not being negative, just being realistic.

No actual numbers, but there are clues. Apple sold 52.2 million iPhones in the quarter. Apple said that "customers chose iPhone X more than any other iPhone each week in the March quarter" (and, incidentally, each week that it was available in the previous quarter after release in November.)

There are 8 total iPhone models that Apple sells (X, 8, 8+, 7, 7+, 6s, 6s+, SE). The average is 6.5 million units per device, so that plus 1 unit is the minimum that the X could be. But average selling price of all iPhones was $728, up from $655 a year ago, so we know that they sold a lot more X and a lot less SE.

I'm going to guess that the iPhone X is in the range of 10 million to 15 million units just for the quarter, or about 750,000 units per week to 1.15 million per week. It could be a little higher or lower, of course, but probably not much more or less. So, 13 million (or 1 million per week) is probably a good guess.

[Sherry_B]

Yep, you got that right...can't wait to see what the "analysts" post tomorrow.

Where exactly are these analysts getting their information?

[TechnologyTwitt]

Are the actual numbers available? Selling 1 can make something a best selling item.

Not being negative, just being realistic.

Stating that "selling 1 can make something a best selling item" is being realistic??

[Lee_Bo]

Stating that "selling 1 can make something a best selling item" is being realistic??

Technically yes.

Just like on the news when it's reported the unemployment rate dropped by 0.5%. That means one person no longer qualified for unemployment benefits.

[Almeuit]

This is why I ignore click bait "doom & gloom" articles for major brands. Most of the time it is just them hoping something bad happens so they get tons of clicks ... But once it comes out it always seems to be either OK or going well.

[kataran]

It’s definitely a FLOP!!

I like the way it flops into my Palm when I take it out of my belt case.

[realtrevorryan]

I came from the 6,7, and 8plus over to the X. I can’t say that it was a flop but that’s what most people do....if it doesn’t live up to ones specific expectations, it’s labeled a “flop”. Oh well. The X still out of some good numbers even if they didn’t I still enjoy flopping mine out daily.

[anony_mouse]

I think you people are missing the point. The iPhone 10 has sold fewer units than Apple were expecting. The fact that it was the best selling iphone is not surprising when you consider that there's actually two versions of most of Apple's other phones - i.e. the 8 and the 8+, 7 and 7+, etc.

Whether that makes it a "flop" I will leave for others to judge.

[msm0511]

I think you people are missing the point. The iPhone 10 has sold fewer units than Apple were expecting. The fact that it was the best selling iphone is not surprising when you consider that there's actually two versions of most of Apple's other phones - i.e. the 8 and the 8+, 7 and 7+, etc.

Whether that makes it a "flop" I will leave for others to judge.

They slightly beat their own expectations when it comes to guidance, so I think that means something. I know it's not broken down my model for guidance, but if we know they sold at least what they thought they would in total, and that the X sold more than any specific model seems like they met expectations. At least to me.

[Vega007]

I do think people wanted it to be a flop, if only to curb the trend of rising cell phone costs. Regardless, I am enjoying mine, and I see it more and more in the wild. While watching the NFL draft last week, I saw plenty of 10's all over the place.

[John Yester]

I agree that the X isn't a flop. But it wasn't that hard for me to get one on release day. I didn't preorder one and I walked into a Best Buy and purchased a 256GB X like four hours after the store opened.

It was not a flop, because most didn't want to walk into Best Buy and drop 1K on a device on release day. Anything lower in price your store would have been empty....

[John Yester]

I do think people wanted it to be a flop, if only to curb the trend of rising cell phone costs. Regardless, I am enjoying mine, and I see it more and more in the wild. While watching the NFL draft last week, I saw plenty of 10's all over the place.

True, it's all media hype. I wake up and in the morning and have not lost sleep over someone wanting to complain on how they think a Billion dollar company should operate. Apple is Successful for these reasons.

[Almeuit]

It was not a flop, because most didn't want to walk into Best Buy and drop 1K on a device on release day. Anything lower in price your store would have been empty....

Agreed. The starting $1k price tag scares some off for sure.

[Almeuit]

True, it's all media hype. I wake up and in the morning and have not lost sleep over someone wanting to complain on how they think a Billion dollar company should operate. Apple is Successful for these reasons.

Yep. The "Doom & Gloom" articles get old. They come out every year... but anyone with common sense knows Apple isn't going anywhere. Even if they do have a bad quarter or something it doesn't mean they are just dead (like some of the click-bait articles try and make it sound).

[Golfdriver97]

Where exactly are these analysts getting their information?

I saw a couple articles where they were basing the theory on reports from part suppliers. They were all apparently saying that them shipping components like ram was down for part of the quarter.

I can try to find the article I read, but it was several days ago.


Edit: found it....https://www.cnet.com/news/for-apple-...ncial-results/

SK hynix stating lower demand is what I am looking at. They are a major memory supplier. Second only to Samsung as I recall.

[Mr Segundus]

It was not a flop, because most didn't want to walk into Best Buy and drop 1K on a device on release day. Anything lower in price your store would have been empty....

I didn't drop $1K on the device. I dropped ~$100 for a DPP for the device.

*shrug*