No. Neither ones did. It had nothing to do with the first ones not working. The recalled the first one because most of them were cracking without even dropping the phone.
Makes sense. I looked back through the thread and it was the Bodyguardz protector that I was thinking about, not Belkin.
I still will vouch for the
Mr. Shield protectors. $6.99 for 5 (were $5.99 when I bought them). Have put them on 4 phones now, never any dust/lint or bubbles, and they all stick well, and cover just enough of the screen. They do include screen sized cleaner stickers, alcohol wipes, cloth, and dust remover strips (I actually use them as hinges for when I lay the screens down). If you have one crack just email them with your order number and they send you another pack of 5 no questions asked. Great service. I have used them on a lot of devices, and have only ever had an issue with the fitment on 1 (original Pixel), which they refunded my purchase for.
I am tempted to try one of the full screen coverage options though. The cutout around the notch doesn't bother me, but the full screen protectors make it look a lot smoother.