I ended up with the elago. I like it a lot. It's simple, thin, feels good. Only thing I didn't think about was that going with a case, you loose that nice feeling of the rounded glass edge. But that was bound to happen.
When I sent in our iPhone 5's to gazelle, they tried to down grade our quote, I think because they thought it was too scratched (the screen was fine). I asked for proof, and they took another look at it and gave us the full amount.
Here's some photos of the elago. My apologies for any weird angles or colors.

Sent from my iDevice using Tapatalk. Please excuse any typos or brevity.