1. spectacularone's Avatar
    Before I bought my iPhone 5, I locked in a trade quote on Amazon for $310 --which was the best I could find anywhere. The caveat was the payment came in the form of an Amazon gift card--but I was okay with that as I figured we could get Christmas gifts there etc. I shipped it off last week and they received it on Tuesday. My account just says "processing".....

    I am starting to become concerned only because since doing all of this--I have read horror stories about Amazon's trade in program (and others). They take your iPhone and claim it's in much worse condition after they have it--and try to offer you less. Then if you want it returned, it comes back to you weeks later without your box and original accessories (all of which I sent in).

    My question is: what are peoples experiences both good and bad with trading in your iPhone? I have always sold mine on Ebay but their fees have gotten so high that I thought this looked like a better deal. Hope I'm just worried for nothing.
    09-28-2012 10:26 AM
  2. SeanHRCC's Avatar
    Why someone would trade their iPhone vs. selling it is still beyond me...i guess people just enjoy giving money away.
    09-28-2012 11:31 AM
  3. v1nn1e's Avatar
    I ended up sending my iPhone 4 to Gazelle for $150. I've sold a phone through eBay in the past, and it was a huge pain. I thought about going the eBay route again, then opted not to after I realized that I would've paid about $25 in fees between eBay and PayPal (if I was able to sell it for $200). Obviously, if I got more than that, the fees would be higher. I think eBay charges 9% off the final sale price, and PayPal charges 3%.. then you have to factor in whatever it'll cost you to ship it (another $10, maybe).

    So, in my case.. I would be out basically $15 (between my "take home" from the eBay route vs. Gazelee). Not worth the headache and hassle.
    09-28-2012 11:33 AM
  4. SeanHRCC's Avatar
    I ended up sending my iPhone 4 to Gazelle for $150. I've sold a phone through eBay in the past, and it was a huge pain. I thought about going the eBay route again, then opted not to after I realized that I would've paid about $25 in fees between eBay and PayPal (if I was able to sell it for $200). Obviously, if I got more than that, the fees would be higher. I think eBay charges 9% off the final sale price, and PayPal charges 3%.. then you have to factor in whatever it'll cost you to ship it (another $10, maybe).

    So, in my case.. I would be out basically $15 (between my "take home" from the eBay route vs. Gazelee). Not worth the headache and hassle.
    If you sold your iPhone 4 on eBay for $200 then you deserve to make little profit...the iPhone 4 is EASILY selling for $275-$300 within a few hours (and that's for the 16GB), the larger capacity will obviously bring more, while looking at the prices before selling my 4S, i saw 32GB 4's upwards of $350-$375. Let's say you sold your iPhone at $300 (plus $10 shipping), you'd pay around $25 in fees to eBay and like $2 to PayPal...leaving you with $283 (round about). Maybe a couple of bucks in gas (MAX)...you come out at the very worst (estimating tax and stuff) with about $275. I don't know about you, but I'm not in the market of throwing away $25, much less $125.

    But hey, if $125 is worth convenience to you, knock yourself out.
    09-28-2012 11:59 AM
  5. Ginbill's Avatar
    I sold my year old iPhone 4 8GB on SPRINT even on eBay for 200 (I wanted to sell fast and took offers) and the fees were only 11.35 I think (didn't use auction setting). Amazon was offering way less than that and I read some horror stories about them giving you only the least amount possible. I would go with eBay if I were you. It sold in a little over 5 hours and I had it shipped out to them from my house. I printed the label here and I didn't even have to drive to the PO.
    09-28-2012 12:22 PM
  6. v1nn1e's Avatar
    Not trying to beat a dead horse, but all of those eBay listings for a used 4 that have a bid price of $300 have ZERO bids. I just did a quick search now, and most are closing somewhere around $250.

    That, and your fee breakdown is wrong. It's basically 13% total fees, plus shipping.

    If I sold it for $300 (which wouldn't happen) - that's $39 in fees, plus shipping costs.. which would basically knock it down $50.
    09-28-2012 12:27 PM
  7. SeanHRCC's Avatar
    Not trying to beat a dead horse, but all of those eBay listings for a used 4 that have a bid price of $300 have ZERO bids. I just did a quick search now, and most are closing somewhere around $250.

    That, and your fee breakdown is wrong. It's basically 13% total fees, plus shipping.

    If I sold it for $300 (which wouldn't happen) - that's $39 in fees, plus shipping costs.. which would basically knock it down $50.
    It's 9%...just did it on their fee calculator, it came out to $27 with shipping cost.

    As far as pricing goes...this was right up at the top, WITH 2 hours left and $15 shipping (which is silly).

    Apple iPhone 4 - 16GB - Black (Factory Unlocked) Smartphone 885909406456 | eBay

    **EDIT - Just wanted to point out that the auction listed above ended at $325...so yeah, there's a lot of profit to lose by simply giving it away to one of these trade in websites...lol.
    Last edited by SeanHRCC; 09-28-2012 at 05:50 PM.
    09-28-2012 12:41 PM
  8. boweveljoe's Avatar
    My SO got lucky and sold her white 4 on Craigslist (16gb) for $250. Results may vary there though.

    I think you should be ok. But some people tend to think something they have been using for a year can still be considered BRAND NEW IN BOX just because they had a case on it etc. They forget that normal wear is still...wear.
    09-28-2012 12:46 PM
  9. piranhadonna's Avatar
    I was thinking about selling my 16g 4s on Craigslist, but I didn't have an extra phone to use until I was able to get the 5. However both AT&T and Best Buy offer buy back programs. I was originally going to go with AT&T for 234, but that didn't work out since they ran out of phones on Friday morning. Best Buy had one left on Friday evening and they held it for me until I could get there plus gave me 260. I was a very happy camper!!!
    09-28-2012 01:03 PM
  10. donnation's Avatar
    You should never ever use a trade in program. I will never understand why people do this, it just doesn't make any sense. Trading in your item is automatically taking a price lower than what it is worth.
    09-28-2012 06:49 PM
  11. kilcher's Avatar
    Selling a $400 iPhone was going to mean $50 in eBay/PayPal fees. Plus I didn't have to have it there until 10/1, allowing me to sell it before many sold theirs and still keep it until after I got my new one. No complaints here.
    09-28-2012 07:09 PM
  12. spectacularone's Avatar
    At the time I sold mine--I did a search of "completed listings" and iPhones with Applecare+ like mine were selling for $335 MAX, some less. I figured the fees and Papal fees would run be at least $40 ($295 net Best case scenario). My other gripe with Ebay: I have been getting low feedback bidders on high dollar items the last couple things I have sold. Me shipping my $335 iPhone to an Ebay buyer with 5 feedback makes me VERY nervous.

    Anyway, I was tempted by the "no hassle" of the Amazon trade price of $310. I don't consider that giving my phone away or leaving money on the table when the best I could possibly do on eBay was $295. The question is will I ever get the $310! I called Amazon today and they are going to follow up with me via email. I will post my results here. The fact is: prices are falling for the 4S as 2.5 million people get the 5.
    09-28-2012 07:24 PM
  13. SeanHRCC's Avatar
    At the time I sold mine--I did a search of "completed listings" and iPhones with Applecare+ like mine were selling for $335 MAX, some less. I figured the fees and Papal fees would run be at least $40 ($295 net Best case scenario). My other gripe with Ebay: I have been getting low feedback bidders on high dollar items the last couple things I have sold. Me shipping my $335 iPhone to an Ebay buyer with 5 feedback makes me VERY nervous.

    Anyway, I was tempted by the "no hassle" of the Amazon trade price of $310. I don't consider that giving my phone away or leaving money on the table when the best I could possibly do on eBay was $295. The question is will I ever get the $310! I called Amazon today and they are going to follow up with me via email. I will post my results here. The fact is: prices are falling for the 4S as 2.5 million people get the 5.
    What iPhone do you have exactly?
    09-28-2012 07:32 PM
  14. Peligro911's Avatar
    I got 389 for my 4s 16 gig plus 15.50 I charged for shipping my fees were like 39 bucks so I basically got 350 after all was said and done and it sold in 2 hours on a buy it now option and to me I think I did good considering my 5 costed me 280
    09-28-2012 08:14 PM
  15. SeanHRCC's Avatar
    I got 389 for my 4s 16 gig plus 15.50 I charged for shipping my fees were like 39 bucks so I basically got 350 after all was said and done and it sold in 2 hours on a buy it now option and to me I think I did good considering my 5 costed me 280
    You must have gone through so much effort and tough work to do that too huh? lol...
    09-28-2012 09:40 PM
  16. Peligro911's Avatar
    You must have gone through so much effort and tough work to do that too huh? lol...
    Tons you know my two minutes taking pic another min doing a description all the effort of pressing list and putting phone in box printing the shipping label I was so exhausted I had to stop to drink a beer lol
    Also worked very hard waiting for my iPhone 5 to arrive via FedEx lol
    09-28-2012 11:13 PM
  17. big9erfan's Avatar
    Sold our 2 year old 16GB iPhone 4 on Craigslist today for $250. Could I have gotten about 275 on eBay? Probably, but fees from eBay and PayPal would have chewed through the rest, and I got the cash in hand today and didn't have to wait for it to clear.

    Our other 4 is being picked up on Monday, just hope the transaction goes as smoothly ( also 250 ).
    09-28-2012 11:40 PM
  18. scorpiodsu's Avatar
    Use swappa people lol.
    09-28-2012 11:44 PM
  19. Jdeezy85's Avatar
    Craigslist.
    09-29-2012 12:04 AM
  20. rstand's Avatar
    I traded mine through Amazon. The process after receipt took two days. The price I got was equal to what I would have gotten on EBAY. The Amazon gift card is the same as money in the bank for someone who uses Amazon a lot and the process was simple.
    09-29-2012 09:41 AM
  21. Icyhot1966's Avatar
    I have 2 perfectly mint white 32GB 4S's going for cheap. I usually sell mine on Howardforums (been a member there for 7 years same username) I am just trying to get $350 each and I have a TON of cases lol. I may try eBay. Both of my phones are Jailbroken.
    09-29-2012 10:26 AM
  22. beto89's Avatar
    I traded in my 64gb 4s to amazon a week before the 5 was announced. Took 4 or 5 days after it was delivered for me to get the money. I'd say be patient. They upheld their offer of $500 for mine so I was satisfied
    09-29-2012 02:49 PM
  23. spectacularone's Avatar
    I got my email and I never would have thought this would have happened but they actually upgraded my condition to "Like New" and gave me $365 for mine. Whew--I feel better having the gift card deposited. I still can't believe they upgraded my condition either. I reported it as "good" and got the original offer for $310. Very pleased to say the least. Interesting to see what others have to say about their experiences. I am not sure if I would or would not do it again. I think it's at least as safe as mailing it to some total stranger with 3 feedback or meeting someone at McDonalds that called me off of Craigslist! Anything is a gamble, really when you are talking $300+ bucks.
    09-29-2012 04:46 PM
  24. scorpiodsu's Avatar
    I have 2 perfectly mint white 32GB 4S's going for cheap. I usually sell mine on Howardforums (been a member there for 7 years same username) I am just trying to get $350 each and I have a TON of cases lol. I may try eBay. Both of my phones are Jailbroken.
    Swappa and amazon are options as well.
    09-29-2012 04:48 PM
  25. boomhower1820's Avatar
    Selling on eBay is ripe for getting ripped off. Pretty much all the buyer has to do is say the box was empty and eBay/Paypal will side with them almost everytime leaving you screwed. God help you if you send it overseas. If you want to sell either forums or craigslist is the way to go. To a lot of people the extra time isn't worth the extra money involved.
    spectacularone likes this.
    09-29-2012 05:13 PM
46 12

Similar Threads

  1. Amazon Affiliates App
    By amazonaffiliateapp in forum iPhone Apps & Games
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 01-30-2012, 12:56 PM
  2. Amazon sent two?
    By Ginbill in forum The iMore Lounge
    Replies: 11
    Last Post: 12-27-2011, 01:22 PM
  3. Amazon MP3s
    By t_williams9476 in forum iTunes
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 11-22-2011, 04:26 PM
  4. Verizon 4S cases on Amazon
    By bkmac in forum Accessories
    Replies: 6
    Last Post: 10-19-2011, 09:23 PM
  5. iPhone Trade In Program
    By OmariJames in forum iPhone 4
    Replies: 6
    Last Post: 06-05-2009, 05:55 PM
LINK TO POST COPIED TO CLIPBOARD