View Poll Results: Love It Or Hate It?

94. You may not vote on this poll
  • Love It

    52 55.32%
  • Hate It

    6 6.38%
  • It's Okay

    22 23.40%
  • It's Not So Hot

    7 7.45%
  • Indifferent

    7 7.45%
  1. Jellotime91's Avatar
    Some of you are a little stuck in the past regarding articles. Please read the Engadget article, look at the January iPad spyshot very carefully. It is real.

    Now that we are basically 90% sure that the leaked iPhone IS the next-gen iPhone G4, are you happy with the design?

    Before you make your decision, here are the reasons I am overjoyed with the new design.

    - Removable battery cover*
    - Glass backing (yes that's right, the same un-scratchable glass that the screen is protected by, no more ridiculous scratches and dirt allover your back)**
    - Beautiful aluminum siding.
    - I liked the volume rocker too, but I think the introduction of these new buttons means they might be user-programmable.***
    - Camera flash.
    - Front-facing Camera.
    - Hot-swappable MicroSIM, compatible with iPad and leaves more room for better components.****

    * You may wonder if production units will actually have a removable battery, because there is still an external SIM ejection mechanism. Why is this? Because the SIM slot and battery are too close together, and having to remove the battery would make it a drag to put your MicroSIM into your 3G iPad that Apple is hoping you will buy.

    Update: Sources are now claiming the back is not meant to be removable by consumers. Still, it is definitely easier than it was previously and doesn't require a tutorial.

    ** Check out Update 2 on the engadget post:
    iPhone 4G: proof -- Engadget
    I'm incredibly excited about this. Sure it might smudge, but you can wipe that off with just about anything. Lets see you wipe off the scratches allover the back of your 3GS with your t-shirt... Ain't happening.

    *** The reason I believe these buttons might be user-programmable is simply because it is no longer a Rocker. I think Apple didn't like the idea of the rocker being treated as two separate buttons, so they created this design solution so that it will not be awkward to use the programmable buttons. Also, we lost some functionality with iPhone OS 4.0, like home button programmability. For that reason, I believe this may be making up for that.

    **** You might think: "No way, Apple and AT&T would never allow it", but let me put it to you this way. A lot of users might want to tether the iPad to their iPhone, however Apple knows AT&T isn't going to allow tethering any time soon. This is Apple's hardware solution to AT&T's hogging ways, and since the SIM is hot-swappable you will get an on-device 3G experience rather than a less reliable tethering experience which also drains your phone's battery. Apple knows you do not want to pay 2 bills for i-Internet, so this is their solution.

    These are all just theories. You might think "This is not like Apple".. But just look at this phone. Look at how open the design has become, and these policies seem much more realistic. Apple is making a big change for the better. They want to silence the critics.

    I find it hilarious how many people said "Indifferent". First of all, you're registered on The iPhone Blog Forums. Secondly, you clicked on this thread for a reason! Obviously you care. And if you clicked it because you believe this leak is fake, I don't know what I can say to you besides wait and see on June 22nd. haha. :P
    Last edited by Jellotime91; 04-21-2010 at 07:52 PM.
    04-18-2010 08:54 PM
  2. RonHC's Avatar

    So far the pics have been proved a knock off since the creator said so

    So whats the real story?
    Last edited by RonHC; 04-18-2010 at 09:19 PM.
    04-18-2010 09:14 PM
  3. Jellotime91's Avatar

    So far the pics have been proved a knock off since the creator said so

    So whats the real story?
    That article is old and needs to be removed/updated further.

    Read the engadget article I linked to, look at the spy shot of the iPad we got the day before its release. Not only is an iPhone (in a case) sitting atop the iPad with a noticeable front-facing cam, but there is also an iPhone (out of case) to the upper-right of the photo with a visible aluminum siding, and you can even see the circular buttons and the new silent switch. Look closely.

    IT'S REAL.

    Believe it.
    Last edited by Jellotime91; 04-18-2010 at 11:39 PM.
    04-18-2010 10:52 PM
  4. msm0511's Avatar
    I think it's possibly a prototype. No way is it a final production model.
    04-19-2010 01:29 AM
  5. Jellotime91's Avatar
    iPhone designs are ALWAYS finalized by January. This is the final design. I think the only thing tha will change is the seems will be removed. It also may not end up having a removable back, but they seem to have built the insides quite beautifully for the back not to be removable.

    My point though is that like it or not, this is the final design. Now I want to know if you... Like it or not! Haha
    04-19-2010 01:37 AM
  6. Blues003's Avatar
    The fact the design is finished by January (which it is) does not mean that is the final design.

    First of all, just because the final design is finished by January, it does not mean that prototypes use that same design. Often, prototypes use cheaper, easier-to-remove-and-access-the-interior materials. The DESIGN is finalized by January. That does not mean that every single phone, even the ones used for testing, will be done on that design. Apple will actually use that design for when they actually SELL the iPhone. They haven't even announced it yet. Don't forget that design it's a theoric concept made real, but only widespread once for sale. As proof, look at the iPad in the same photograph. Can you identify it as an iPad prototype? Sure. Is it the same as the ones for sale? Hell no.

    Finally, if that was the final design, then why does it have the weird logo? Shouldn't that be "real"? One could surely argue it was for secrecy. But if that is so - and Apple has a fame or being one of the tighest companies regarding that -, then all the remaining shell can be made up as well to cover the true design.

    The pictures appear to be real. But being real =/= being our future product.
    04-19-2010 06:22 AM
  7. msm0511's Avatar
    Exactly blues0003. Jon Gruber from daringfireball who is almost always right thinks it is a test unit not a production unit. Why would Apple forego their signature style completely for what is IMO a step backward design-wise.

    I don't think it's hideous, but more Nokia than Apple. If this is the final unit I don't think I'll be upgrading.
    04-19-2010 08:36 AM
  8. cardfan's Avatar
    I'll upgrade. Heck, i'd preorder without even knowing what it looks like. Doesn't matter. :P
    04-19-2010 08:55 AM
  9. DataCentre's Avatar
    I don't really care either. If it's ugly looking and I can swap out the battery, I will still buy it. Love to keep a couple of extra batteries on hand. Always had a couple of spares when I owned Blackberry. Don't always have access to a plug.
    04-19-2010 09:55 AM
  10. ghostface147's Avatar
    I am on the fence about this possible final design. However I feel if it was the final design, Apple would be sending cease and desist letters to the websites. There are just a couple of things that are wrong with this prototype that make me believe that it is not a final design, but more of a tech demo unit of some sort. At a time when Apple is moving everything to non-user replaceable batteries, why take a step back on it? The seams also question it's authenticity.

    I guess we'll find out when it's released late June/early July. I am hoping that this isn't the final design because it's ugly based upon these pics. However when I actually get to see one first hand and play with it, judgement may change.
    04-19-2010 10:15 AM
  11. Jeremy's Avatar
    If this were the final product or not I would not be shocked either way. But I like it a lot actually after the gizmodo shots. Pretty slick.
    04-19-2010 11:09 AM
  12. Ipheuria's Avatar
    I'm not sure if anyone has seen this article yet today Apple's 4th-generation iPhone revealed -- Engadget but what do you guys think?? At first I thought it was either rumor or a knock off just didn't look like Apple's usual design. However Endgadget has said they connected it to iTunes and it is recognized as an iPhone so damn I'm excited cause I LIKE it
    04-19-2010 11:25 AM
  13. Ipheuria's Avatar
    So I'm talking to my friend today and he started telling me about the leaked images of the 4th gen iPhone:

    This Is Apple's Next iPhone - Iphone 4 - Gizmodo
    Apple's 4th-generation iPhone revealed -- Engadget

    So the story first was that someone found it at a bar and took it back to endgadget. When I first saw it I thought it was a knockoff or it was just a hoax because the style is so different from the previous generations which have all been pretty close. Then I thought knowing Apple and their secrecy about their products Steve Jobs would find out who the employee was and look at him and he would spontaneously combust. However if you think about it, if they need to use a higher resolution screen and new hardware to stay with today's market and innovate they will need to change things. I looked at the pictures and I started to drool and now I'm hoping this is actually the 4th gen iPhone. Then I'm thinking this would be the best way to build hype so maybe Apple concerted the whole thing? especially after seeing the pictures of it being opened up. So what do you guys think about the whole story? the pictures? weigh in on it.
    04-19-2010 01:00 PM
  14. Ipheuria's Avatar
    I am seriously drooling over these pictures. Well like I did with the iPad when rumors started to swirl I have already started saving because in June if the 4th Gen iPhone looks like the pictures I WILL be getting on pronto.
    04-19-2010 01:03 PM
  15. redbeard's Avatar
    Why would the screen size get smaller? That makes no sense.. And why did It say 80GB on the back over the weekend and XXGB today?
    Last edited by redbeard; 04-19-2010 at 01:07 PM.
    04-19-2010 01:04 PM
  16. ghostface147's Avatar
    This design is slowly growing on me. However I can't seem to get it out of my mind that Apple is going the opposite direction against non-user replaceable batteries with this possible model. Those seams also just don't seem like something Apple would do.

    I will withhold final judgement until it is officially announced and I can have some hands on time. It's all about how the customer personally likes it right?
    04-19-2010 01:09 PM
  17. redbeard's Avatar
    04-19-2010 01:15 PM
  18. Ipheuria's Avatar
    Thanks for the link never seen that. Yeah at first the design just made me go nope that's a hoax it just seemed so un-Apple like but the more I looked at it the finish and the gleam I was digging it. It just doesn't seem like Apple to leak it two months away though and for sure Apple's lawyers would be on the ball to get the images torn down from the website and the phone back. If this is it though I am so loving it and I'm getting one ASA it drops.
    04-19-2010 01:20 PM
  19. Jellotime91's Avatar
    You guys are wrong.. Too lazy to quote everyone but actually the ipad on that table is exactly what was released. It was in a bolted to the table in a large metal enclosure, still the same ipad. Also, when we had a 3GS "prototype" and it looked just like the 3G people thought it wasn't the final design - guess what, it was.

    This alone is proof enough that this is the final design, and honestly if you think this is a step backwards in design I question your taste. I find the 3GS to be incredibly ugly. Not only is this new design better looking, but it is more sturdy and a hell of a lot more accessible.

    Just wait until June 22nd and you'll see exactly how right I am, and you'll be surprised how much better it looks when the seams are removed.
    04-19-2010 01:50 PM
  20. iquinn's Avatar
    I hate to say but I really don't like it yet. I'm sure it will grow on me and it won't keep me from getting it when it comes out, but there is just something about that does not look as elegant as the 3GS.
    04-19-2010 01:51 PM
  21. ghostface147's Avatar
    I would just think that if they were real, Apple would immediately send a cease and desist letter. As stated previously, the design is slowly growing on me.
    04-19-2010 02:06 PM
  22. BLiNK's Avatar
    well all of this hype has made it to the front page of MSN

    @Ipheuria, i remember a while back you had mentioned something about the new iPhone possibly looking like the old style Nano...

    can you also let me know what this weeks Powerball numbers are?
    04-19-2010 02:09 PM
  23. BriDroid's Avatar
    Personally, I loved the form-factor of the iPhone 2G, was less awe-inspired by the 3G and 3GS, and feel that if this is indeed the G4, then I'm pleased as punch in that it more resembles the 2G
    04-19-2010 02:26 PM
  24. Ipheuria's Avatar
    I hate to say but I really don't like it yet. I'm sure it will grow on me and it won't keep me from getting it when it comes out, but there is just something about that does not look as elegant as the 3GS.
    See it's so funny when I read the tipb blog about it and saw so many people saying they hate the design it was so weird. I love the design it was a bit different at first compared to the usual iPhone shape and design so I was thrown a bit but I LIKE it. You can never please all the people all the time.

    Powerball hmmmmmm 1,4,6,28,32 and 37 if you win I want 50K of it though LOL

    My friend and I were talking and just trying to reason things out and it's just hard. It just seems too early to beleive that Apple would leak it on purpose to create marketing hype. If it was two or three weeks away from the launch it would be feasable but 2 months that seems too long a period of time. We thought maybe Apple is trying to ride the wave of success of the iPad and after the international customers have been told they have to wait for another month maybe they wanted to create positive hype . So customers would see 1 month as a short period of time while drooling over the new iPhone and still having to wait for 2 months. I personally love the look of this leaked phone, front facing camera, new camera lens on the back with flash and a higher res screen plus OS 4 the anticipation has just begun.
    04-19-2010 02:49 PM
  25. echaos1210's Avatar
    I hate it, it looks to much like an HTC product they need to come better with the design....and if this is the design i guess ill be getting a new iphone 3GS
    04-19-2010 03:03 PM
127 123 ...