1. stiffeon's Avatar
    So first off I am an Apple fanboy. I just love Apple over Windows and currently own a late 2013 MBP for my main work device and an iPhone 6s Plus. I run Windows on Parallels when I absolutely have to use Windows and that's it.

    So I have never owned a tablet. I don't know why, but I never really felt I wanted an in-between device between my MBP and iPhone. I always felt the larger iPAD Pro was too big and the Air 2 just wasn't powerful enough to justify my needing it since I do a lot of Office suite work and note taking for grad school. Then the 9.7 came along and I really started doing my research...

    I'm an IT professional by trade and I am also a current grad student. With that in mind, I really compared the iPAD with Microsoft's Surface Pro because in many cases I need a reliable form of Windows to run certain programs and sometimes my VM setup just falls short. I also questioned the fact that the Surface is running a full OS while the iPAD is running a mobile OS. And lastly, I looked at what I wanted to use it for.

    I ended up going with a 9.7 128gb with pencil and smart keyboard. Here's why:

    1) I want to get rid of all my 5 subject notepads and convert them onto a tablet. I like writing out notes because I learn better that way, and by doing it on a tablet I save space, more organized, and more green. Both systems can do that but the Apple pencil got really good reviews so I chose that tool.

    2) I hate Windows. Simply put, I felt like I would be disappointed being stuck in Windows, however, I do question why Apple will not start putting at least a hybrid version of OS X on the new IPAD Pro. I feel they are losing some the market because of this and Tim Cook is wrong in thinking this is a full laptop replacement because it can't be considered that without simple things such as file management. That's subjective, but that's my stance on that and it would of made my decision easier had Apple went with something more OS X - ish.

    3) I already have 2 Apple products so full integration between the 3 devices will be nice. iMessage, FaceTime, sharing Word/Excel docs between them, etc.

    4) Cost. I think at first glance some would see the Surface as cheaper. But when you compare performance I feel you need to bump the surface up to the i5 processor / 128gb storage and that's about $200 more with their smart keyboard purchase, granted you get a bigger screen on the Surface, but I am not considering the tablets as MBP replacements and more like a convenience luxury item between my phone and MBP workhorse.

    5) Battery life. A tablet to me is a luxury device. Meaning I don't want to be troubled charging it much and iPAD seems to have great battery life.

    My biggest questions I won't be able to answer until I have the product. Maybe you current iPAD enthusiasts can chime in here. Like will I be able to use split view effectively on a 9.7" screen? I could easily change my order to the larger screen but I really don't want something that big in my briefcase with my MBP. However, will I be disappointed when trying to split view? I will be using split screen a lot with grad school projects so between that and note taking are the 2 biggest uses. I am also hoping to dabble some in the art apps as well to use the pencil more. Also are there other uses that this will be good for that I am not seeing? Like once I have it maybe I'll think "I don't know why I didn't get a tablet sooner." I hope so. Otherwise it's hard to justify the $1000 I just invested in this. Maybe a slight case of buyer's remorse but I am definitely excited at same time
    austriak likes this.
    03-27-2016 12:23 AM
  2. phreddyl's Avatar
    I ordered a 128 9.7 with the pencil and the keyboard- I am personally not a fan of split view but I don't really use it for work. i have had an iPad since they first came out and its the one device other than my phone I cannot live without- I would say use the 14 days apple gives you and try it out- you can always return for the larger one
    stiffeon and ladyc0524 like this.
    03-27-2016 12:26 PM
  3. stiffeon's Avatar
    Good advice, thank you. This will be my first tablet. Why do you feel the iPAD is a device you cannot live without?
    03-27-2016 02:55 PM
  4. Sander Soots's Avatar
    You see, iPad is missing touchpad. And it's impossible to do research properly on tab (50 tabs open, few documents open etc. is not an option on ipad at the same time, while it is for surface or your macbook). I have iPad Air 2 and Macbook Pro Retina. Whenever I need to do school assignment I open up my laptop. I use tablet as note taking tool at class with my external keyboard and entertainment. I have Parallels Access there that theoretically can replace my need for portable laptop aslong as I have server to connect to but 9.7" size is seriously limiting and I end up using it only when I leave my Macbook behind. Don't get me wrong, if you invest in apps, have ecosystem to support it you can do a lot on iPad. But it's not going to be fun.

    Having that said that, here are few comments on your points:
    1. Use OneNote. Superior handwriting recognition and best in class notebook management and sharing.
    2. It is a perfect companion device. Companion device is meant mostly for consumption with minor production.
    3. Word/Excel is nice with basic features but say table of contents is already to complicated...
    4. Unless you are running VM's on your tablet you don't need to bump it from I3. i3 will be about as fast as iPad for most things. i5 outperforms any tablet, i7 has heating issues if we are comparing to Surface. And if you plan on running VM's on your tablet anything else than light work you are crazy (hint: not because it cant, but think of the heat).
    5. iPad will do better than any other tablet in general uses. Bump it up with hardcore graphics and battery life is worse than Surface.
    stiffeon likes this.
    03-28-2016 03:26 PM
  5. stiffeon's Avatar
    Solid points. I really enjoyed reading your feedback and I'm looking forward trying out some of the applications and trying to make the most of it.
    03-29-2016 12:35 PM

Similar Threads

  1. Unlocked or t-mobile 5SE? Anyone order from Costco?
    By Slammed925 in forum iPhone SE
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 03-27-2016, 12:16 PM
  2. Where can I get the star tracker lite for my Macbook Pro?
    By iMore Question in forum MacBook Pro
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 03-27-2016, 12:56 AM
  3. My Apple TV is not working just has a flashing light?
    By iMore Question in forum Apple TV
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: 03-26-2016, 03:45 PM
  4. iPad Pro 9.7 or iPad Air 2?
    By mcammarata7 in forum iPad Pro Series
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 03-26-2016, 12:09 PM
  5. Why can I not find my real racing game after I updated my iPad to 9.2.1?
    By iMore Question in forum iPhone Apps & Games
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 03-26-2016, 12:03 PM