iKaraoke, the karaoke app for iPhone, one more incoherent appstore rejection story

[Silicon Studios]

Hello we are Silicon Studios,

the developers of several pioneer iPhone OS apps like:

iTouchMidi, the first suite of midi controllers*on the app store
iDownload, the first and top downloader app on the app store

We have recently developed iKaraoke,*the karaoke player for the iPhone OS
the app would allow users to play .kar files and play them displaying the
lyrics,
it would also include built in access to +3500 public domain tracks

the app has been pending approval since march 12,
and we just received a really incoherent and inaccurate rejection from
appreview team
stating it is duplicating ipod functionality despite playing
totally*unsupported*files and showing lyrics in real time

they also stated that as the app managed the files by itself it would be too
confusing for users


Please tell us what you think about it

 

[Jellotime91]

Wow that is totally ridiculous and I for one would love to have a karaoke app.
How is the program managing it's own files confusing for the user?