[Mike Velasquez]

I'm looking to buy my girlfriend an Apple Watch for Christmas and she seems interested in the 42, but I'm afraid it would be too big. She's 5'8"

[teejaywhy]

I chose 38mm sport, but I am 5'4" and wanted something small and light weight. If she wants 42mm then that's what you should get. She knows what works for her.

[malt1977]

Get the 42, it can always be changed after.

[firstborn80]

I tried on both and decided I like the 38 more. If she wants the 42 that's what you should get. She has time to decide if she likes it or not.

[Ledsteplin]

There's no way to tell which to get from what other women say. She really needs to try them on. Just pick one and if it doesn't fit, return it for a different size.

[Hellenek]

I went with the 38 and it was an excellent decision. It's not too large or too small. Most of the time I'm looking at black glass - didn't want it to be too big.

Is she able to try it first?

[LVMHgirl]

I love big watches so of course I got the 42 and I LOVE my choice. (And I am 5'4".)

I recently got a cuff band which makes it look even bigger, lol.

Give her the one she wants!

[ladyc0524]

I got the 38 because it's the perfect size for me