That's kind of where I am leaning. The design I'd use is not likely to be too easily warped but I was going to call and ask about sizes and resolutions. Because it doesn't appear any image works without resizing no matter how huge!
Aside from the horrible printing issues, did you like the case? I don't know how I feel about the squishy rubber part but it looks like it would work ok with a screen protector based on how it goes on.
Aside of the image getting FUBAR'd, YES i did like the tough case. The black silicone is mostly covered obviously because the plastic shell outter going over it. The way the black silicone part sticks out a bit from the shell is similar to a Speck cs, except with a little more silicone exposed on the tough case. I have considered getting another CM Tough case from them, BUT i would stick with a ready made print....perhaps the leopard one. I swore after the DIY i wouldnt purchase a case again from them, but i can't deny that i did like the style of the case itself
and as for protection, i'd measure it equal to the cs. You can place your phone face down without the screen touching the immediate surface. Also, i have the PowerSupport HD anti-glare SP on my phone and it did NOT interfere with the case being on it either.
If you have an AT&T corporate store near you, i'd suggest stopping in and checking out the tough case - most of them carry it OR you could call first, regardless of print just so you can physically see and try on the case as well
I do wish CM had a few color selections as far as the under layer of silicone casing goes too.