I've used an otterbox commuter and a similar incipio case which was the only one available when the plus was released at my verizon store. I just received a Tech 21 Impactology Case and I'm very impressed. I was looking for the wallet/folio style case but I wanted one that would protect my device. This case feels sturdy and it looks very professional, I decided to go with this style to keep my screen safe and I have the apple watch now so don't always have to have the screen exposed.