On impulse, I did pick up one of the new Otterbox Preservers despite it not having a holster. I do like it. The only issue that I have with it thus far is that it won't work with one of my aftermarket power cords because the plug won't fit into the aperture on the case. I also had the re-input my fingerprints to get the sensor to work better.
The fingerprint sensor worked a little better with the Defender, but the Defender sensor hole isn't covered with the waterproof tape and is larger.
I typically use 3 fingerprint slots for my thumb and two for my index finger, and I've never had any problems with it not working. Either the tape cover on the Preserver interferes a little, of the hole is smaller and it's more difficult for my phone to recognize my fingerprint. But it does work pretty well now that I've reimput my fingerprints with the new case on.
Posted from my iPad using Tapatalk HD.