Welcome to the iMore Forums Create Your Account or Ask a Question Answers in 5 minutes - no registration required!

View Poll Results: Did the screen size give you a negative opinion of the new iPhone 4S?

Voters
67. You may not vote on this poll
  • Yes

    42 62.69%
  • No

    25 37.31%
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 25 of 34
Like Tree17Likes
  1. Thread AuthorThread Author   #1  
    SeanHRCC's Avatar
    iMore Genius

    Posts
    8,524 Posts
    Global Posts
    8,526 Global Posts
    iOS Version
    Taco Bell

    Default Lack of larger screen the source of the majority of negative opinions...

    So you'll start seeing this more over the next few days, but it appears that most people, when asked, were primarily upset about the new iPhone 4S because of one single fact...the phone didn't have a larger screen.

    Is this true amongst the TiPb members as well? Vote in the poll and let's find out.

    Would the iPhone 4S have been a more universally accepted product if they had simply added real estate to the screen?

    To me, it mattered so insignificantly that when i saw the screen was the same, i was actually excitedly anxious to learn more about the new features of the phone...i could give a flip about a 4" screen (that most likely would decrease battery life and honestly, not make a huge difference on...well...ANYTHING related to viewing whatever you're looking at on the iPhone screen). We have this retina display that kicks the a$$ of anything else on the market for the time being.

    Are so many people really losing sleep over .5" of screen space? Please tell me the silly notion that a bigger screen makes a better phone that so many Android fan boys seem to push onto the world, is not infecting those who love/d the iPhone over the years...I'd certainly hope that the same people defending the iPhone 4's retina display BEFORE the rumor of a bigger screen would still have the same basic logic they had then, since nothing has changed between now and then...AT ALL.

    What say you?
    Last edited by SeanHRCC; 10-04-2011 at 09:49 PM.
    "Speed has never killed anyone; suddenly becoming stationary...that's what gets you." - Jeremy Clarkson
  2. #2  
    Netherscourge's Avatar
    iPhone Intermediate

    Posts
    100 Posts
    Global Posts
    220 Global Posts

    Default

    I agree.

    #1 complaint - same screen size
    #2 complaint - same glass case




    .5" is a BIG deal in the Smartphone world...


    As is the case in ALL situations, size DOES matter.


  3. #3  
    Fausty82's Avatar
    iMore Genius

    Posts
    8,597 Posts
    iOS Version
    iOS 7.1 b5

    Default

    Where are all of the LED fans? No weeping and gnashing of teeth on their part?

    I guess the fact that the LED flashing option in the Accessibility section of the OS Settings didn't really mean squat, eh?
    Curmudgeon and Former Member/Participant
    iPhone 5S / iPad Mini Retina / 15" MacBook Pro Retina
    chenzo51 and Adawg1203 like this.
  4. Thread AuthorThread Author   #4  
    SeanHRCC's Avatar
    iMore Genius

    Posts
    8,524 Posts
    Global Posts
    8,526 Global Posts
    iOS Version
    Taco Bell

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Fausty82 View Post
    Where are all of the LED fans? No weeping and gnashing of teeth on their part?

    I guess the fact that the LED flashing option in the Accessibility section of the OS Settings didn't really mean squat, eh?
    I'm thinking...had the whole iPhone 5 w/ a 4" screen rumor not happened...the "bigger screen" complaints would have fallen into the "didn't really mean squat" category as well.
    "Speed has never killed anyone; suddenly becoming stationary...that's what gets you." - Jeremy Clarkson
  5. #5  
    Premium1's Avatar
    iMore Guru

    Posts
    1,959 Posts
    Global Posts
    1,373 Global Posts

    Default

    It isn't 2007 people like larger screened phones hence why manufacturers except apple are making larger screens and hd screens that match what apple can only do on a 3.5 inch screen.
    Adawg1203 likes this.
  6. #6  
    DaPhoneking's Avatar
    iMore Expert

    Posts
    861 Posts
    Global Posts
    2,477 Global Posts
    iOS Version
    6.0

    Default

    I think that the screen is not only the issue, but some people were hoping for a redesign alltogether.
  7. #7  
    gthugballin's Avatar
    iPhone Intermediate

    Posts
    133 Posts
    iOS Version
    5.0

    Default

    the screen did it for me... not getting it
  8. #8  
    Fausty82's Avatar
    iMore Genius

    Posts
    8,597 Posts
    iOS Version
    iOS 7.1 b5

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by redraider133 View Post
    It isn't 2007 people like larger screened phones hence why manufacturers except apple are making larger screens and hd screens that match what apple can only do on a 3.5 inch screen.
    And this is the part where you vote with your wallet. If you like it, buy it. If not, buy something else. Not really a hard thing to figure out or implement.
    Curmudgeon and Former Member/Participant
    iPhone 5S / iPad Mini Retina / 15" MacBook Pro Retina
  9. #9  
    Premium1's Avatar
    iMore Guru

    Posts
    1,959 Posts
    Global Posts
    1,373 Global Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Fausty82 View Post
    And this is the part where you vote with your wallet. If you like it, buy it. If not, buy something else. Not really a hard thing to figure out or implement.
    Ha i planned on it thanks for you approval and allowing me to do that. /s
    Not to mention they emphasized gaming but who really wants to play games other than angry birds on a 3.5 inch screen.
  10. Thread AuthorThread Author   #10  
    SeanHRCC's Avatar
    iMore Genius

    Posts
    8,524 Posts
    Global Posts
    8,526 Global Posts
    iOS Version
    Taco Bell

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by redraider133 View Post
    It isn't 2007 people like larger screened phones hence why manufacturers except apple are making larger screens and hd screens that match what apple can only do on a 3.5 inch screen.
    Nobody has made one that can match Apple yet...so the argument is moot until one has.

    Bigger is Better huh? lol...Apple has been doing great with the exact opposite line of marketing/thinking, and i think people will be surprised that Apple will continue to do great with this new iPhone 4S.

    People are falling victim to their own hype fall out...and its hilarious!
    "Speed has never killed anyone; suddenly becoming stationary...that's what gets you." - Jeremy Clarkson
  11. #11  
    imex99's Avatar
    iPhone Newbie

    Posts
    13 Posts
    Global Posts
    888 Global Posts

    Default

    Voted yes because i'm used to my 4.3 inch screen from my evo 4g and my evo 3d. I'm getting my wife an iphone 4s for sprint and was thinking about one for myself but not with a screen smaller than 4 inches. IMHO, 4.3 inch screen is perfect but would live with a 4 inch.
  12. #12  
    diggity's Avatar
    iMore Beginner

    Posts
    67 Posts
    Global Posts
    175 Global Posts
    iOS Version
    5.0

    Default

    This is not a big deal for me. I won a Droid X in a contest on Android Central, and wasn't really all that impressed with the larger phone size. I ended up selling the X and keeping my Incredible with the 3.7" screen, which I must say was a very cool Android phone.

    I'm not in the market to change from my 4 at the moment. But if I was, I would be very happy knowing that my element vapor pro case would still work the 4S (presumably).
  13. #13  
    Premium1's Avatar
    iMore Guru

    Posts
    1,959 Posts
    Global Posts
    1,373 Global Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by SeanHRCC View Post
    Nobody has made one that can match Apple yet...so the argument is moot until one has.

    Bigger is Better huh? lol...Apple has been doing great with the exact opposite line of marketing/thinking, and i think people will be surprised that Apple will continue to do great with this new iPhone 4S.

    People are falling victim to their own hype fall out...and its hilarious!
    Well see next week when the prime is announced with its hd screen if it matches the iPhone. Still doesn't change the fact its easier to have a retina display on a smaller screen.
    Last edited by redraider133; 10-05-2011 at 10:13 PM.
    Adawg1203 likes this.
  14. #14  
    CG68's Avatar
    iMore Pro

    Posts
    524 Posts
    Global Posts
    680 Global Posts
    iOS Version
    7.0

    Default

    I had a Droid X with a 4.3" screen and thought I would miss it when I moved to the iPhone 4. I adjusted fairly quickly and with the retina display it more than makes up for the loss of screen real estate-for me IMO. In addition, the phone is much more pocketable now which I enjoy. As stated by the OP, the larger the screen the more that the battery life will suffer.
    iPhone 5S - iPad Air - MacBook Pro 13" - ATV3

    + Romans 8:28 +
  15. #15  
    Caballera's Avatar
    iMore Intermediate

    Posts
    150 Posts
    Global Posts
    151 Global Posts

    Default

    To me lack of a bigger screen made all the difference. If the iPhone 4S had all the updates announced today plus a larger screen size, I would without a doubt be waiting to pre-order one on Friday. However with my current iPhone 4 I just don't feel the need to upgrade. I will instead wait till next year to upgrade my iPhone.

    My wife who's using a iPhone 3GS, is upgrading, and she's really excited about it. I also think she would use Siri a great deal.
    iPhone 4S 16GB (Black) | iPhone 4 16GB (Black) | iPhone 3GS 16GB (Black) | iPod Touch 4G (2010)| MacBook 13" Spring 2011 | iPad 3rd Gen (Black)
    @Caballeraz
  16. #16  
    Jellotime91's Avatar
    iPhone Elite

    Posts
    2,484 Posts
    Global Posts
    2,485 Global Posts

    Default

    Absolutely not. I have been adamant that the screen size on the iPhone is big enough, and that the retina display resolution makes it feel a lot more substantial than other larger, lower-res screens.

    I just wanted something different. Honestly, the iPhone 4 could seriously benefit from a more curvy figure. I won't want another 3GS, but this thing gets uncomfortable on long phone calls!

    Also, with the advent of the notification center, even though I originally opposed the idea, I really think the notification LED is necessary.. I'm definitely going to be jailbreaking to get notification icons in the status bar. Without that, it has been bothering me a little having to check if I have notifications waiting or not.

    After mulling it over, though.. I have come to realize that, aside from the redesign, this is the exact same device that the iPhone 5 would have been... Once you accept that, and if you were already happy with the iPhone 4 design, why is it meaningful at all to have a new design? Plenty of people who saw the alleged iPhone 5 design thought it was really ugly! Design is subjective.
    Last edited by Jellotime91; 10-04-2011 at 10:45 PM.
     iPhone 4 32GB
     MacBook Air 13.3" (May 2011)
     iPad 2 16GB
  17. #17  
    redbeard's Avatar
    iMore Specialist

    Posts
    1,040 Posts

    Default

    You silly people that wanted certain improvements! Just be happy with what daddy Apple gives you, whiners..
  18. #18  
    briankeith513's Avatar
    iMore Intermediate

    Posts
    291 Posts
    Global Posts
    1,527 Global Posts
    iOS Version
    iOS 6.0.1

    Default

    I would have wanted a 4inch screen and LTE. So, although it's not enough of an upgrade for me, since I already have the IPhone 4, it's a nice device, and probably will still be the best device on the market, until the next IPhone arrives.
    -I don't know who u are, I don't know what u want. If u are looking for a ransom, I can tell u I don't have money, but what I do have are a very particular set of skills; skills that I have acquired over the course of watching Chuck Norris in Walker, Texas Ranger, skills that make me a nightmare for people like u.


    -I am not Neo, But I am still the One.

    http://i44.tinypic.com/v6roqw.gif
  19. #19  
    DaPhoneking's Avatar
    iMore Expert

    Posts
    861 Posts
    Global Posts
    2,477 Global Posts
    iOS Version
    6.0

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by briankeith513 View Post
    I would have wanted a 4inch screen and LTE. So, although it's not enough of an upgrade for me, since I already have the IPhone 4, it's a nice device, and probably will still be the best device on the market, until the next IPhone arrives.
    For me I wished for LTE and an aluminum back. Its kinda stupid to cover up a pretty phone with a ugly, bulky case or cover because Apple decided to make the whole thing practically out of glass. Plus I can't use my dock without taking my case off which is stupid.
  20. #20  
    jd78's Avatar
    iPhone Newbie

    Posts
    28 Posts
    Global Posts
    32 Global Posts

    Default

    I currently have a Nexus S 4G through Sprint and did not realize the iPhone screen will be smaller. I assumed that it would be about the same size, but not as big as the larger screens seen on Evos.

    Is it enough to keep me from switching... Sort of. I would really like to get an iPhone and the camera improvements alone make it a tempting buy for me. However, if say the iPhone 5 comes out next summer, am I going to regret not waiting it out?
  21. #21  
    melwan's Avatar
    iPhone Intermediate

    Posts
    295 Posts
    Global Posts
    472 Global Posts
    iOS Version
    5.0 GM

    Default

    Did you guys really think Apple would change the screen size and screw developers over? They wouldn't do that until at least 2-phone cycles has gone by; until they can kill off the 3GS. Once that happens, then we have Retina iP4/iP4S and Retina iP5.

    2 sizes/resolutions at a time to keep the developer experience reasonable.

    And yes, believe it or not, Apple does care about the developers experience. They wouldn't have released the most complete and feature-rich SDK on the market ever in the mobile industry.
    http://db.tt/a5VqEks
    Happy Syncing.....
  22. #22  
    Jellotime91's Avatar
    iPhone Elite

    Posts
    2,484 Posts
    Global Posts
    2,485 Global Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by melwan View Post
    Did you guys really think Apple would change the screen size and screw developers over? They wouldn't do that until at least 2-phone cycles has gone by; until they can kill off the 3GS. Once that happens, then we have Retina iP4/iP4S and Retina iP5.

    2 sizes/resolutions at a time to keep the developer experience reasonable.

    And yes, believe it or not, Apple does care about the developers experience. They wouldn't have released the most complete and feature-rich SDK on the market ever in the mobile industry.
    As long as they didn't change the resolution it would have no effect. I design iPhone apps.

    Also, jailbreak devs have shown that even if they did increase the res slightly (to about 1080x720) they could still use the same retina display source imaging and make most apps automatically scale to the new res (except games).
     iPhone 4 32GB
     MacBook Air 13.3" (May 2011)
     iPad 2 16GB
  23. #23  
    chenzo51's Avatar
    iPhone Newbie

    Posts
    22 Posts
    iOS Version
    4.2.1

    Default

    Larger screen would have been nice but I really wanted no glass back and led notification light. But we will se how good the notification center is, maybe we will not need the light. But I still think it would have been real easy to do in a new form factor or the current one. I guess I'll be buying one of those metal backs from Ally and not worry about busting it up. That's why I would have liked a redesign
  24. #24  
    Jellotime91's Avatar
    iPhone Elite

    Posts
    2,484 Posts
    Global Posts
    2,485 Global Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by DaPhoneking View Post
    For me I wished for LTE and an aluminum back. Its kinda stupid to cover up a pretty phone with a ugly, bulky case or cover because Apple decided to make the whole thing practically out of glass. Plus I can't use my dock without taking my case off which is stupid.
    Err... Well, one could definitely argue that a case is not needed... I actually have found over my 4 iPhone 4s that I've had in the past year that cases tend to scratch the back of the device more than using it without a case.

    In terms of dropping the phone, I have dropped it SO MANY times, even this latest one, my fourth (and final) iPhone 4, I have dropped easily over a dozen times. Each time more cringe-worthy than the last, but it always turns up completely spotless. Not a single scratch, no cracks, not even a dent on the stainless steel band. And a couple times I definitely thought it was a goner, it has really been smacked face-down on my floor - hard.

    I'm definitely not saying it can't break, but if you are relatively careful with it, you should be fine without a case. Also with the new Apple Care+ if you have an accident I think it's only $49 additional to replace it, which is pretty amazing because it's not Apple's fault that you broke it, and they're giving you up to an $850 replacement.
     iPhone 4 32GB
     MacBook Air 13.3" (May 2011)
     iPad 2 16GB
  25. #25  
    LazyStarGazer's Avatar
    iMore Pro

    Posts
    641 Posts
    Global Posts
    11,767 Global Posts
    iOS Version
    Sicks

    Default

    Larger screen would have been nice, but compared to my 3GS, this phone is 4-10 times faster/better at various functions.
    Should feel like a night and day improvement.

    AND... my 64GB wish came true!!!!!
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Posting Permissions