iPhone 3G article on the Yahoo homepage
Seven problems with the new iPhone : Christopher Null : Yahoo! Tech
What do you guys think about what this guy wrote in his article? I don't think I'd like live TV on my iPhone. Isn't that an extra $10 or $20 bucks through AT&T?
Last edited by iLoveiPhones; 06-29-2008 at 07:45 PM.
- 06-29-2008, 08:05 PM #2
- 06-29-2008, 10:10 PM #4
they are looking to make a slingbox version for Blackberry, and i would LOVE to have one for the Iphone...
- 06-30-2008, 01:17 AM #6
I think those 7 things things people should know about the phone before they buy it, so it's pretty valid article to write. But pretty much every phone has 7 things wrong with it, it's just a matter of it having what you need.
So I think a similar article can, and has been in many cases, written about most other phones.
For the first iPhone, the deal breakers for me were:
1) No 3G, 2) No Exchange Activesync support, and 3) No 3rd party apps.
Apple has addressed those 3 things so now it's going to be a great product for me. The others are pretty much non-issues to me.
Nothing's perfect, but it is it what you want? Yes? Buy it. No? Get something else.
And addressing the first one #1, the cost.
It's no more or less expensive than every other PDA option from AT&T.
I'm not sure it should be counted as "something wrong" with it.
- 06-30-2008, 06:12 AM #7
The total cost of ownership thing is getting to me now...
When a new WinMo device like the Tilt comes on the market for $550 retail, or $350 after subsidies and rebates, you never see articles popping up about the cost of ownership over 2 years. Why do "journalists" feel the need to do this for the iPhone? Just because it is popular? Bah...
At&t Tilt - $350 (at release)
8gig SD Card - $150 (roughly the cost when the Tilt was released)
24 months at $75/mo for minimum voice + data and 200 SMS ($40 v + $30 d + $5 t)
Total = $2300
iPhone 3G 8 gig = $2000
But the iPhone catches flak for it?
The same thing applies to the upcoming BlackBerry Bold. It too will have a $30 data plan, a minimum of a $40 voice plan, and text messaging is separate starting at $5 for 200. If the Bold costs $1 more than the 8gig iPhone 3G, it will be more expensive to own over time. Rumors are saying that the Bold is pretty much guaranteed to cost more to buy (they point to $300 after rebate and subsidies) and there is nothing rumored about needing to purchase an SD card to make up for not having the memory included with the iPhone, that part is a fact. Why not write "articles" about the Bold and use this as a negative for it, like the iPhone?
Speaking of memory, what planet does the author of that article live on? 8 gig is substandard? 16 barely cuts it? I'm sorry, but I can't think of more than a very small handful of phones sold today that come preloaded with that much memory, yet he uses it as a negative for the iPhone?
I am not saying that he doesn't make a few valid points, but the article is generally off base.
Last edited by CrazEtooN; 06-30-2008 at 06:15 AM.
- 06-30-2008, 06:54 AM #8
- 06-30-2008, 09:23 AM #9
CrazETooN hit the nail on the head with every comment. EVERY subsidized converged device (phone/PDA) carries a stiff data plan requirement and total cost of ownership. In fact, iPhone I was the antithesis of the standard model with higher up front prices and lower data plans than any other phone (try being a BB BES customer for a while at $45 per month for the data component only).
In fact, I am a bit surprised by all the complaining about $30 vs. $20. There isn't a 3g service that I know of that doesn't cost more than the 2-2.5g alternative, so how is that $10 even a fair factor in the TCO?