Welcome to the iMore Forums Create Your Account or Ask a Question Answers in 5 minutes - no registration required!
Results 1 to 17 of 17
  1. Thread AuthorThread Author   #1  
    Neutrino's Avatar
    iPhone Intermediate

    Posts
    235 Posts
    Global Posts
    413 Global Posts
    iOS Version
    6

    Default Is Apple and AT&T at War?

    Interesting blog below from iProng. Is Apple and AT&T at war? What does this suggest about the status of the exclusivity arrangement?





    Taken together with this link from the Washington Post, what does this say about early upgrading? Wait and see?



  2. #2  

    Default

    I think this is BS.

    The upgrade policy is nothing new to the iPhone. AT&T has always had a two year upgrade policy. The modified it slightly last year to help iPhone users, but there is no reason to feel that would would, or should, have to do the same thing this year.

    Truthfully, the people whining about "I can't upgrade" need to read the contract with AT&T before they signed it. No, you can't. You can't upgrade to a new iPhone, you can't upgrade to a Blackberry, you can't upgrade to an LG - nothing. To think that AT&T is targetting iPhone users and trying to screw them reeks of arrogance.

    If AT&T offers an early upgrade option (something they have never offered in a blanket fashion to other phone users like they did last year to iPhone users) than it is a bonus - but it shouldn't be expected or demanded!


    Chris
    Please remember to like or thank posts that are useful, entertaining, or beneficial.

    Twitter: @skeetobite | Google+: ChrisVitek | Game Center: DRSKEETO


    Current Devices: iPad Air 128GB Wifi | iPhone 5S 64GB AT&T
    PDAs: Visor Deluxe | Visor Prism | Zire 72
    Phones: Treo 680 | iPhone 3G | iPhone 3GS | iPhone4 | iPhone 4S | iPhone 5
    Tablets: iPad 1 64GB AT&T | iPad 2 32GB Wifi | iPad 3 64GB Verizon LTE

  3. #3  
    Joe McG's Avatar
    iMore Intermediate

    Posts
    282 Posts
    Global Posts
    283 Global Posts

    Default

    OK, so I've been seeing Chris' argument on alot . . .

    I understand that the cost of the phone is partly subsidized over a certain time period. However, you can't use that argument without looking at the numbers.

    I was with Tmobile for 4 years until I got an iPhone in January. I upgraded several times with them. Their subsidy was spread out over the first 11 months and was basically done with the monthly charges for the PHONE SERVICE.

    In the case of AT&T they are subsidizing it over an 18 month period. At the same time, they are charging a required $30 per month iPhone data fee. This was increased $10 for the 3G to subsidize for the phone. HOWEVER, they are still getting the $50 - $100 per month for PHONE SERVICE on top of that and do not have to pull the subsidy from that at all. Not only that, their phone service is MORE EXPENSIVE than Verizon, Sprint, and Tmobile. THIS IS DOUBLE (TRIPLE) DIPPING.

    Not only that, but their text messaging rates are enormous compared to Tmobile!

    While I know that it is reasonable for AT&T to make iPhone users wait 12 months to wait for an upgrade, 18 months is too long and is not inline with Apple's product cycling, so something needs to be done.

    P.S. If you really want an iPhone 3GS, just buy it, and sell your 3G on Ebay. They're selling between 200 - 400 dollars right now.
  4. #4  

    Default

    Different carriers, different pricing plans, different subsidy plans...different scenarios.

    Some carriers subsidize the phone more than other, some have cheaper plans more than others. You can't compare them directly - it is comparing apples and oranges.

    AT&T subsidizes phones more than Verizon (and I think more than Sprint, not sure about T-Mobile).

    If you don't like AT&T's policies, don't sign a contract with them. As simple as that. Don't sign a contract, then complain when AT&T adheres to the terms of that contract. Yes, if you want the iPhone in the USA, you need a contract with AT&T (or buy an unlocked phone via Ebay) but still, no one is forcing you to sign it.

    AT&T doesn't answer to Apple - to say "it isn't in line with Apple's product cycling" is ludicrous. They are two separate companies - why don't you tell Apple to get in line with AT&T's contract upgrades? That arguement makes just as much sense.
    Please remember to like or thank posts that are useful, entertaining, or beneficial.

    Twitter: @skeetobite | Google+: ChrisVitek | Game Center: DRSKEETO


    Current Devices: iPad Air 128GB Wifi | iPhone 5S 64GB AT&T
    PDAs: Visor Deluxe | Visor Prism | Zire 72
    Phones: Treo 680 | iPhone 3G | iPhone 3GS | iPhone4 | iPhone 4S | iPhone 5
    Tablets: iPad 1 64GB AT&T | iPad 2 32GB Wifi | iPad 3 64GB Verizon LTE

  5. Thread AuthorThread Author   #5  
    Neutrino's Avatar
    iPhone Intermediate

    Posts
    235 Posts
    Global Posts
    413 Global Posts
    iOS Version
    6

    Default

    Here's another interesting perspective regarding whining iPhone 3G nerds:

  6. #6  
    The Reptile's Avatar
    iPhone Newbie

    Posts
    31 Posts
    Global Posts
    33 Global Posts

    Default

    Cold war - yes. It's probably got to do with exclusivity and AT&T's inability to upgrade it's network fast enough. Any accountant could figure out how many months are required in a commitment to allow for the upgrade to the new iPhone 3GS. Any DBA could write a SQL script to change the setting in all iPhone owner's accounts to change the MMS setting. AT&T has known that Tethering was on its way and could have had a plan ready with pretty marketing data. And AT&T also knew that a $99 3G was on it's way and could have had new rate plans ready. Since all of this is routine then the only reason why they don't have things done yet has to be a feud.
  7. #7  
    bandman77's Avatar
    iPhone Newbie

    Posts
    11 Posts

    Default

    I hate the 2 year upgrade term. I am 3 months away from my 2 year upgrade, and they will not allow me any leeway. It can just be frustrating. I would pay slightly more in order to bypass that 3 month time waiting period too.
  8. Thread AuthorThread Author   #8  
    Neutrino's Avatar
    iPhone Intermediate

    Posts
    235 Posts
    Global Posts
    413 Global Posts
    iOS Version
    6

    Default

    A similar story from pcworld:

  9. Thread AuthorThread Author   #9  
    Neutrino's Avatar
    iPhone Intermediate

    Posts
    235 Posts
    Global Posts
    413 Global Posts
    iOS Version
    6

    Default

    Wall Street is very happy with Apple's WWDC keynote announcement:

  10. #10  

    Default

    One other thing. People with iPhones are acting like this is targetting them. This is a standard AT&T policy. You don't hear LG users complaining when a new LG phone come out. You don't hear Blackberry users sayins AT&T hates them when a new Blackberry comes out. What makes iPhone users so high and mights that they think they deserve special treatment?

    Chris
    Please remember to like or thank posts that are useful, entertaining, or beneficial.

    Twitter: @skeetobite | Google+: ChrisVitek | Game Center: DRSKEETO


    Current Devices: iPad Air 128GB Wifi | iPhone 5S 64GB AT&T
    PDAs: Visor Deluxe | Visor Prism | Zire 72
    Phones: Treo 680 | iPhone 3G | iPhone 3GS | iPhone4 | iPhone 4S | iPhone 5
    Tablets: iPad 1 64GB AT&T | iPad 2 32GB Wifi | iPad 3 64GB Verizon LTE

  11. Thread AuthorThread Author   #11  
    Neutrino's Avatar
    iPhone Intermediate

    Posts
    235 Posts
    Global Posts
    413 Global Posts
    iOS Version
    6

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by cjvitek View Post
    One other thing. People with iPhones are acting like this is targetting them. This is a standard AT&T policy. You don't hear LG users complaining when a new LG phone come out. You don't hear Blackberry users sayins AT&T hates them when a new Blackberry comes out. What makes iPhone users so high and mights that they think they deserve special treatment?

    Chris
    It's the Apple mystique. The honor of being the first on the block to get a really cool device. Sorry, the LG devices don't turn me on. Don't tell my wife that since I'm probably getting her an ENV. I enjoy my Blackberry Storm. But, in my opinion, it lacks the coolness factor of the iPhone.
  12. #12  
    jhamilton3's Avatar
    TiPb Fourm Staff

    Posts
    1,742 Posts
    iOS Version
    iOS 7.0

    Default

    All I know is AT&T better start making up with Apple because I don't want to go through the hassle of switching to Verizon..
    Twitter = JHamilton24
  13. #13  
    jamesus's Avatar
    TiPb Forum Staff

    Posts
    1,893 Posts
    Global Posts
    1,898 Global Posts

    Default

    I switched to AT&T on July 11th last year and I am available for a partial upgrade on July 12th of this year, which is 1 year from my 2 year contract date. In my years at Sprint, I was only eligible for a partial rebate after 18 months. I'm happy with AT&T's policy.

    And I agree with Chris. If you don't like the contract terms, don't sign up for the contract...
    http://twitter.com/jamesus

    If I have helped you, don't forget to tip the scales!
  14. #14  
    Frozen001's Avatar
    iPhone Beginner

    Posts
    97 Posts
    Global Posts
    232 Global Posts

    Default

    Here is a random spin on the AT&T Apple battle...

    It is rumored that Verizon will have the Pre early next year. This means that sprint's deal with palm will have come to an end. Could AT&T be talking to palm about a GSM Pre?
  15. Thread AuthorThread Author   #15  
    Neutrino's Avatar
    iPhone Intermediate

    Posts
    235 Posts
    Global Posts
    413 Global Posts
    iOS Version
    6

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Frozen001 View Post
    Here is a random spin on the AT&T Apple battle...

    It is rumored that Verizon will have the Pre early next year. This means that sprint's deal with palm will have come to an end. Could AT&T be talking to palm about a GSM Pre?
    They have already mentioned having a GSM version of the Pre as well as the new model, rumored to be the replacement for the Centro, called the Eeos.
  16. #16  
    Frozen001's Avatar
    iPhone Beginner

    Posts
    97 Posts
    Global Posts
    232 Global Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by iPhonejunkie3 View Post
    They have already mentioned having a GSM version of the Pre as well as the new model, rumored to be the replacement for the Centro, called the Eeos.
    So I wonder if this has soured things with Apple then. You could definatly see Apple was not happy with AT&T during the keynote, and they were very blatent to bash the Palm Pre. After all AT&T is technically the only US Carrier for the iPhone, so if they were also to get a Pre, I am sure apple will take a hit in market share.
    -------------------

    Follow me on Twitter
  17. #17  
    legendofdon's Avatar
    iPhone Beginner

    Posts
    50 Posts
    Global Posts
    589 Global Posts

    Default

    I think the problem is that most people don't understand what happened last year when the 3G came out.

    The original iPhone wasn't subsidized like other phones. Therefore your eligibility for a subsidized phone remained intact. When these same people upgraded to the 3G, which was subsidized, they used that eligibility to get the phone at the $199/$299 price by signing the 2 year contract. ATT lets customers get another subsidy at 18 months. It's only been 12 months. So that means you aren't eligible for another subsidy. That's the way phone contracts have always worked. The whiners have nothing to whine about.

    Not knowing the rules is not ATT's fault.

Posting Permissions