Thanks for the replies, here's the real issue I'm having:
I noticed today that when I make a reminder via Apple Watch Siri it is confirming the reminder is made, but then I can't see the reminder in the Reminders app on iPhone, or on iCloud.com.
The watch is confirming reminder creation, but no reminder is being created. Here's where it gets weirder. I use Fantastical 2 on Apple Watch to see reminders. If I add a reminder with a due time it will show on Fantastical but not in iPhone reminders app. Even weirder I DO get the notification for the reminder on my watch.
This is driving me nuts. If I just make the reminder on AW via Siri without a due time it confirms creation, but then it's lost in the either. Help!
Apparently others are having this problem as its on the apple forums. And the support person I spoke to said others are having the problem.