Welcome to the iMore Forums Create Your Account or Ask a Question Answers in 5 minutes - no registration required!

View Poll Results: Apple tv vs. xbox 360

Voters
40. You may not vote on this poll
  • Apple TV

    10 25.00%
  • Xbox 360

    17 42.50%
  • Other

    7 17.50%
  • I have both...

    6 15.00%
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 25 of 37
  1. Thread AuthorThread Author   #1  
    rgar3388's Avatar
    iPhone Intermediate

    Posts
    225 Posts
    Global Posts
    226 Global Posts
    iOS Version
    5.0.2

    Default Apple TV vs. XBOX 360

    I'm in the market to buy a device to stream content. I want all your opinions. Should I buy the new apple tv, or an xbox 360? I go back and forth on whether or not I'll actually play video games, but the plus side is that it can play dvds.
  2. #2  
    Duvi's Avatar
    iMore Guru

    Posts
    1,937 Posts
    Global Posts
    19,870 Global Posts

    Default

    I'd go w/ the xbox. The fact that it has the ability
    to do the video games or play DVDs would be enough
    for me to go that way.

    Current Phones: iOS, Android, Windows Phone, BlackBerry OS & WebOS
  3. #3  
    ChrisGonzales90's Avatar
    iPhone Specialist

    Posts
    1,335 Posts
    Global Posts
    1,646 Global Posts

    Default

    Xbox offers a lot more then just "TV show rentals"
  4. #4  
    Mella's Avatar
    iMore Intermediate

    Posts
    401 Posts

    Default

    Well, days before maybe I'll choose Xbox, but now as AirPlay is an easy way to stream digital media from the iPad to an Apple TV, and also bcz the Apple TV can already access iTunes, more I have got the iFunia iPad video suite for my videos and movies wathcing on the go, so Iwould like to choose the series of apple products, use iPad and Apple TV together~~
  5. #5  
    farbod21's Avatar
    TiPb Jailbreak Genius

    Posts
    909 Posts

    Default

    I have both, but it all depends on if you are going to play games...
    -iPhone4 iOS 4.1 (Greenpois0n Jailbreak)
    -iPad iOS 4.2.1 (Redsn0w Jailbreak [Tethered])
    -AppleTV 4.2 (SHSH Saved)

  6. #6  
    sting7k's Avatar
    iMore Elite

    Posts
    2,585 Posts
    Global Posts
    3,391 Global Posts
    iOS Version
    7.0.2

    Default

    I'd say it really depends if you are heavily invested in Apple or Windows. If you have a Mac then your Xbox will stand alone. Yes it can do a lot more than the AppleTV but with a PC it does even more. The Xbox does everything an AppleTV can do and lots more.

    One of it's strongest features IMO is when combined with Windows Media Center and a TV tuner. No more paying for an HD cable box when your PC has it's own guide and can record TV, then just stream it to your Xbox.

    The only real downside is to get all of the bells and whistles you need Xbox LIVE which is $60/year. You can normally find a year subscription card online for less though. With that though you get online gaming, voice chat, ESPN3, etc. Really the only thing the Xbox can't do is play Blu-rays.
  7. #7  
    peanutgallery's Avatar
    iPhone Intermediate

    Posts
    132 Posts

    Default

    I have both but as I play fewer and fewer games I turn my xbox on less and less. I rarely have time for anything other than the occasional NCAA football game. I still use it to stream Netflix and watch DVDs but I find that I'm using the AppleTV more and more to watch Netflix simply because the menu is quicker to get to and the xbox has a lot of other stuff I don't care about in the way. I do prefer the xbox set up of Netflix over the AppleTV though. I really appreciate the percentage watched guide. Sometimes I have noticed the AppleTV Netflix to not recognize where I am in a TV series.

    It's funny though because I never streamed digital media through the xbox from my laptop, but now I use my AppleTV to stream digital copies of DVDs all the time. I think it's because I never cared for Windows media player, although I don't think all that highly of iTunes either, but it is the lesser evil I suppose. It might help that I can sync the same files to my iPhone through iTunes too.

    All that paired with the $60 xbox live subscription made me vote for the AppleTV
  8. #8  
    sting7k's Avatar
    iMore Elite

    Posts
    2,585 Posts
    Global Posts
    3,391 Global Posts
    iOS Version
    7.0.2

    Default

    You don't use Windows Media player to stream. You use Media center or Zune software both of which are much nicer. In fact now that I think about I think it specifices you can't use WMP to stream to an Xbox.
  9. #9  
    uhanrodric's Avatar
    iPhone Intermediate

    Posts
    249 Posts
    Global Posts
    254 Global Posts
    iOS Version
    4.3.5

    Default

    Xbox if you want to be able to purchase content, store it, and view it later. As stated in ealier post, Windows Media Center, let's you do a lot of what Air Play does from a PC. So in theory you could *LEGALLY* rip your content to your PC and stream to your Xbox. Plus the ability to play a game, should the mood ever strike, not too bad.

    If all you're looking to do is stream your iPad's iTunes on your TV, then just go with APPLE TV.
    iPhone 5 16GB, iPad 32GB Wi-fi, Mac Mini(2010)
    Twitter - @UhanRodric
  10. #10  
    Jeremy's Avatar
    Administrator

    Posts
    7,048 Posts
    Global Posts
    10,099 Global Posts
    iOS Version
    iOS 6

    Default

    I have both. But if you are in the market for a single device then I'd go with the one that has the capability to do more things. So Xbox.
  11. #11  
    9thWonder's Avatar
    iPhone Intermediate

    Posts
    130 Posts
    Global Posts
    1,378 Global Posts

    Default

    Xbox 360 hands down cause it does more then apple tv but a WD TVHD live media is a better streamer.

    Xbox simply provides nearly all the functionality and more. you get games, stream from your desktop, more formats then apple tv, stream netflix, espn 3, facebook, twitter. Appletv is basically just a netflix streamer and a way to buy stuff off of Apple. I personally have never bought music of videos from itunes so its' just not useful. Nor can apple tv stream the majority of the content stored on my 1.5 terabyte hard drive.

    Personally, i have xbox 360 for only for gaming now And use a WD tv HD live media cause it does all that xbox does and way more, 1080p, mkv, files over 4GBs, dts, Mp4, supports .iso, .ts, avi, divx, streams netflix. And i'd buy a WD TVHD way before i bought an apple tv because it just does way way more formats.
    Last edited by 9thWonder; 12-08-2010 at 02:08 PM.
  12. #12  
    jordandev's Avatar
    iPhone Nanite

    Posts
    1 Posts

    Default

    If you want to be able to play games and DVDs get an Xbox. If not get an Apple TV. It's as simple as that.
  13. #13  
    mdntblu's Avatar
    iPhone Newbie

    Posts
    46 Posts

    Default Xbox

    My Xbox does EVERYTHING. I don't have any other devices connected to my TV except my Xbox.
    I use it for Games, netflix, play DVD's, Facebook, Twitter, ESPN, streaming movies from my NAS, Using Playon to watch TV shows/Movies through Hulu, etc. And now I just had it setup as my Uverse receiver so I can watch my Uverse TV and control my DVR from it.
    And Xbox Marketplace seems to be very up to date and we rent movies on there all the time.
    Xbox FTW
  14. #14  
    Tobias Funke_mndd_2's Avatar
    iPhone Nanite

    Posts
    3 Posts

    Default

    Playstation 3. Why is it not on the list? Netflix, Blu-Ray, DVD, Games, bam. No required monthly online fee is a major plus.
  15. #15  
    jayman16's Avatar
    iPhone Nanite

    Posts
    6 Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by rgar3388 View Post
    I'm in the market to buy a device to stream content. I want all your opinions. Should I buy the new apple tv, or an xbox 360? I go back and forth on whether or not I'll actually play video games, but the plus side is that it can play dvds.
    The Xbox hands down. It is so much more capable. It plays games, does DVD's, has Netflix, ESPN, Last.fm, has a very robust movie and tv library for purchase or rental.

    Plus I use Rivet () and it let's me play all my content from my Mac to my Xbox. Music, pictures, video, movies. It will hook up to iTunes and iPhoto and you can also specify directories for it to find media. I have a Drobo that hold all my "legally ripped" movies and tv shows and Rivet streams those all perfect from the Drobo to my 360, with their intact folder structure.

    Mac+Rivet to the Xbox 360 makes the connectivity between a Windows machine and the Xbox look clunky and out dated.

    I have an Apple tv as well that we keep in the bedroom, it's nice but Airplay is pretty lame in this iteration and Netflix is dog-slow on the aTV.

    The 360 is more robust and has killer features, I'm a huge gamer and I'll bet only half of my time on the 360 is for gaming that's how useful of a media center it is.

    Also spend the $300 and get the new Xbox with the built-in WiFi and 250GB HDD, the $200 model comes with a lame 4GB flash drive.

    Send me an email or PM if you have questions.
  16. #16  
    jayman16's Avatar
    iPhone Nanite

    Posts
    6 Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Tobias Fnke View Post
    Playstation 3. Why is it not on the list? Netflix, Blu-Ray, DVD, Games, bam. No required monthly online fee is a major plus.
    Because it sucks? Streaming content is horrible compared to the 360. The "online" is free and you get what you pay for. No one has mics, inconsistent lobbies interfaces, Netflix requires a disc...
  17. #17  
    futurecode's Avatar
    iPhone Intermediate

    Posts
    134 Posts
    iOS Version
    iOS5

    Default

    It think really does come down to if you game or not. If you have no interest in gaming and want just streaming then go apple tv, if you see yourself or family gaming now or in the future then go gaming console which, in my opinion, the PS3 holds the crown.

    As a Apple TV, 360, wii and PS3 HTPC/Gaming PC owner, my "what I use the most" roll call goes: PS3, HTPC, Apple TV Wii, 360.

    Then again, I game a lot. If I did not, the PS3 and HTPC would b neck and neck, then the apple tv and wii, then 360.

    It's funny actually, I have HTPC and still find myself using my PS3 over that for streaming, just for the simple UI and convenience. You can use it for Gaming in full HD up to 7.1, Netflix in full HD up to 5.1 , Blu-rays, DVD's, #d movies and Gaming, Motion Gaming, a built in web browser for Facebook, Twitter, TiPB, ESPN, everything web based really, buy / rent movies over the PSN network (free) you can stream your network movies (MKV, AVI, etc..) images and music with PS3 media server (free), really, just about everything the Apple TV, 360, wii and HTPC/Gaming PC can do sans a few things here or there.

    It's my "all in one" media server winner by a mile.
    Last edited by futurecode; 12-08-2010 at 02:36 PM.
    "I'd give it all up, for just a little bit more"
  18. #18  
    futurecode's Avatar
    iPhone Intermediate

    Posts
    134 Posts
    iOS Version
    iOS5

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by jayman16 View Post
    Because it sucks? Streaming content is horrible compared to the 360. The "online" is free and you get what you pay for. No one has mics, inconsistent lobbies interfaces, Netflix requires a disc...
    Baseless and fanboyish to a T. back up what you say, otherwise stop trolling. The person who posted the topic wanted to know what does what so they can choose a streamer, not "why you hate another piece of equipment". State facts or helpful opinions, not just fanyboyisms.
    Last edited by futurecode; 12-08-2010 at 02:48 PM.
    "I'd give it all up, for just a little bit more"
  19. #19  
    Tobias Funke_mndd_2's Avatar
    iPhone Nanite

    Posts
    3 Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by jayman16 View Post
    Because it sucks? Streaming content is horrible compared to the 360. The "online" is free and you get what you pay for. No one has mics, inconsistent lobbies interfaces, Netflix requires a disc...
    Netflix doesn't require a disc(anymore) Streaming content is just as good as 360 (I have both). PS3s dont break nearly as often as 360s. I am on my 3rd Xbox, I have a friend on his fifth or so. They always need to be sent in for repair but Microsoft does a decent job with that. Players not having mics can be seen as as major plus because a majority of online players are annoying when on Mics. Never had a problem with the online on PS3, just as good as XBox live. The drone of the XBox's (they sound like they are about to take off) is a constant annoyance.
    Last edited by Tobias Fnke; 12-08-2010 at 02:38 PM.
  20. #20  
    uhanrodric's Avatar
    iPhone Intermediate

    Posts
    249 Posts
    Global Posts
    254 Global Posts
    iOS Version
    4.3.5

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Tobias Fnke View Post
    Playstation 3. Why is it not on the list? Netflix, Blu-Ray, DVD, Games, bam. No required monthly online fee is a major plus.
    PS3 Lacks Windows Media Center, which allows you to stream from a PC. Which you're not REQUIRED to pay a monthly fee to do, since it's just happens over your home network.
    iPhone 5 16GB, iPad 32GB Wi-fi, Mac Mini(2010)
    Twitter - @UhanRodric
  21. #21  
    futurecode's Avatar
    iPhone Intermediate

    Posts
    134 Posts
    iOS Version
    iOS5

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by UhanRodric View Post
    PS3 Lacks Windows Media Center, which allows you to stream from a PC. Which you're not REQUIRED to pay a monthly fee to do, since it's just happens over your home network.
    Wrong. You can use WMC to stream to your PS3 ..... or tversity, or play on, or PS3 media server, really, a ton of options when it comes to streaming. Just pick one and go with it. The " required monthly fee" was directed to Netflix, ESPN3, really almost all of Xbox "connect/stream from the internet" "apps" require this to function.
    Last edited by futurecode; 12-08-2010 at 02:54 PM.
    "I'd give it all up, for just a little bit more"
  22. #22  
    uhanrodric's Avatar
    iPhone Intermediate

    Posts
    249 Posts
    Global Posts
    254 Global Posts
    iOS Version
    4.3.5

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Tobias Fnke View Post
    Netflix doesn't require a disc(anymore) Streaming content is just as good as 360 (I have both). PS3s dont break nearly as often as 360s. I am on my 3rd Xbox, I have a friend on his fifth or so. They always need to be sent in for repair but Microsoft does a decent job with that. Players not having mics can be seen as as major plus because a majority of online players are annoying when on Mics. Never had a problem with the online on PS3, just as good as XBox live. The drone of the XBox's (they sound like they are about to take off) is a constant annoyance.
    What in Jebus's name are you two doing that you needed that many Xbox's??!?! I'm still rockin' my original 20GB model from way back when....
    iPhone 5 16GB, iPad 32GB Wi-fi, Mac Mini(2010)
    Twitter - @UhanRodric
  23. #23  
    jayman16's Avatar
    iPhone Nanite

    Posts
    6 Posts

    Default

    I'm not here to get in a pissing match. I bought a 360 (20GB) and PS3 (20GB) both the days they launched. And other than a few PS3 only games (MGS4, Uncharted, LBP) I never used and sold it. The system updates on the PS3 took no less than 30 minutes up to a hour over my 12Mbps connection to download and install, compared to my 360 with takes maybe 3 minutes to download, install, and reboot. Trying to get media to stream to the PS3 was like pulling teeth from a Mac or PC. It was easier to install Linux that stream media to the damn thing. Once I finally the did, it was choppy and the controls were awful.

    Great no disc anymore for Netflix? Welcome to Xbox 2 years ago. Yes Xboxes used to have a high fail rate, but not anymore ever since the 'Jasper' MoBo's no more RRoD.

    I'm not saying some people might not like the PS3, but if you're looking for ease-of-use I don't know how anyone could recommend the PS3 over the 360. To me: the Xbox 360 is equal to the iPhone. Yeah it's more of a closed off system but **** just works better and easier (streaming, online play). And the PS3 is more like an Android device. Built for the "tinkerer" and modder, someone whom likes to get their hands dirty.
  24. #24  
    Tobias Funke_mndd_2's Avatar
    iPhone Nanite

    Posts
    3 Posts

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by UhanRodric View Post
    What in Jebus's name are you two doing that you needed that many Xbox's??!?! I'm still rockin' my original 20GB model from way back when....
    They never lasted for more than a year/18 months, most of the time still under warranty, sent it in, Microsoft sent me a New/Refurbished Xbox.

    @Jayman

    You're joking right? 360s are cheaply made pieces of crap. If the motherboard doesn't go out on you, the cheapo CD tray will. Xbox has Halo and Left 4 Dead, that is about it.
    Last edited by Tobias Fnke; 12-08-2010 at 03:06 PM.
  25. #25  
    futurecode's Avatar
    iPhone Intermediate

    Posts
    134 Posts
    iOS Version
    iOS5

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by jayman16 View Post
    I'm not here to get in a pissing match. I bought a 360 (20GB) and PS3 (20GB) both the days they launched. And other than a few PS3 only games (MGS4, Uncharted, LBP) I never used and sold it. The system updates on the PS3 took no less than 30 minutes up to a hour over my 12Mbps connection to download and install, compared to my 360 with takes maybe 3 minutes to download, install, and reboot. Trying to get media to stream to the PS3 was like pulling teeth from a Mac or PC. It was easier to install Linux that stream media to the damn thing. Once I finally the did, it was choppy and the controls were awful.

    Great no disc anymore for Netflix? Welcome to Xbox 2 years ago. Yes Xboxes used to have a high fail rate, but not anymore ever since the 'Jasper' MoBo's no more RRoD.

    I'm not saying some people might not like the PS3, but if you're looking for ease-of-use I don't know how anyone could recommend the PS3 over the 360. To me: the Xbox 360 is equal to the iPhone. Yeah it's more of a closed off system but **** just works better and easier (streaming, online play). And the PS3 is more like an Android device. Built for the "tinkerer" and modder, someone whom likes to get their hands dirty.
    Just because you personally, through use and familiarity, find the 360 "easier" does not, in the end, make the PS3 "difficult". Just because the an F1 driver can't ride a bicycle does not make riding a bicycle "more difficult" than formula 1 racing. The PS3 and 360 are made to be used by the lowest common denominator (aka: the general public) so by no mean are either system difficult to use. The facts are that either system is just as easy to stream to given the appropriate (similar to both systems) knowledge. It comes down to which system offers more and maybe if one system has a monthly fee or not, plain and simple. Don't get upset if other people do not favor the system you favor, you will live a very stressful life.

    P.S. This is just my personal take on your diatribe and nothing to do with this topic (I guess?), but nice try trying to say a Microsoft product is like an Apple product, high comedy my friend!

    P.S.S. OP, maybe you should just go with an apple TV just to avoid any of these type conversations! HA!
    Last edited by futurecode; 12-08-2010 at 03:16 PM.
    "I'd give it all up, for just a little bit more"
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Posting Permissions