View Poll Results: Do you care about NFC?
- 125. You may not vote on this poll
No thanks, Minority Report
Yeah, It'd make my life complete
Maybe I would in the next 2 years
Tim Cook says I don't need it... so I don't
Do you even care about nfc?
I have it on my phone. First thing I did was turn it off.
(Edit: I posted a CNET article about the suckiness of NFC below)
- I don't want things that I walk by talking to my phone randomly, feeding Skynet information.
- I don't want battery drain from something I'll encounter once every month.
- The only thing NFC is good for yet is paying without a card... no thanks Skynet, I'll just pull out my wallet, which I carry anyway.
- If I want you to have my contact info, I can walk up to you and let our phones make love... or I can send you a vcard from anywhere, in roughly the same amount of time.
- There is already a near-field communication that lets me control exactly what I send and receive, it's called bluetooth... and that one already talks to my headphones and car. (If it could talk to my girlfriend for me when I get home, it'd be even better).
And finally... Apple didn't put it in their device, so no one will adopt it anyway.
Last edited by jrsharp70; 09-12-2012 at 10:50 PM.
- 09-12-2012, 10:10 PM #2
- 09-12-2012, 10:24 PM #4
I've owned an iPhone, iPad, MacBook, and iMac. I've spent ~$1,000 on iTunes.
And Apple drives the entire tech market... I'm interested in how they will make the competition better.
I'd say even if none of the above were true, posting on the forum while not currently typing on an iPhone isn't a crime.
Last edited by jrsharp70; 09-12-2012 at 10:32 PM. Reason: typo
- 09-12-2012, 11:00 PM #7
Just like Kilo said, that PayPass logo is found more and more places ... Heck I pay at the water / soda machine by just touching the phone. Money comes right out of my checking account instantly. Pretty amazing never having to dig out my wallet to grab a card to swipe.
- 09-12-2012, 11:34 PM #8
- 09-13-2012, 01:20 AM #9
NFC is a mess right now.
Apple wouldn't want to jump into that mess.
Remember the leak saying Apple abandoned the NFC?
Probably because it's a mess and it's gona get that lots of minus points if it doesn't work well. and probably ain't even close to 60% as fast as paying with a credit card.
Perhaps say next year or 2014? When NFC is starting to become more reliable?
- 09-13-2012, 03:31 AM #10
- 09-13-2012, 03:41 AM #11
I think people don't understand what NFC is. Sure, it has a feature to pay for things, but remember WebOS and tap to share? Being able to move a web page, games, or any saved data from just tapping phone to another device. Imagine being able to tap your iPhone to your iMac, with iTunes up, and instantly your iPhone 5 syncing. No connection required. Imagine having a movie on your iPhone and tapping your iPad, or even your Apple TV, and bam, that movie ... Right where you stoped watching it ... Is now on the big screen.
Apple had a chance. They could have shown innovation. They choose evolution. Nothing wrong with it, sure, but when they show this next year with the iPhone 5s, you can't say they invented it. Because they will be copying the million Android devices and WP devices doing these things.
Heck, the whole Nexus Q is a cool idea. That's innovation.
- 09-13-2012, 03:42 AM #12
I don't think it's Google's fault that carriers are trying to not be dumb pipes and get into the payment picture. There are ways to load Google Wallet on to Verizon phones.
- 09-13-2012, 07:37 AM #13
It's an infant tech...bottom line. When it get's on it's feet and it's readily available in a more wide spread nature, I'll consider it a more pressing option, right now, i personally don't have a need for it...that's not to say everyone should feel the same, but I'm not making decisions on new phones based on the inclusion of NFC or not.
- 09-13-2012, 07:38 AM #14iMore Nanite
- 7 Posts
Not so useful where I live
In most of the stores were I live NFC or even passport really wouldn't be that valuable feature. The reason is most of the card readers require a card oriented swipe and not just a hold of a card close to the reader. The exception I can think of is Exxon gas stations where they do have the tap n go and some McDonald's which have a fast pass.
If the stores would change the readers then I really would like to have both these features.
- 09-13-2012, 07:41 AM #15
I usually don't like seeing people downplay something that's not added (or taken away) but this isn't one of them.
- 09-13-2012, 07:45 AM #16
- 09-13-2012, 07:58 AM #17
There are a lot of uses for NFC and payment is just 1 little feature. Access to private fueling facilities, buildings, etc.
The problem is their haven't been a lot of developers making apps for it.
1 company did it for the Blackberry and it was really cool. Turning profiles off and on depending on where you were.
- 09-13-2012, 08:06 AM #18
- 09-13-2012, 08:12 AM #19
HID, the company that makes proximity security cards just announced they will be supporting Blackberry's NFC. I suspect they don't want to touch Android yet since the security on those is scary. But I'm sure they will also take on Windows Phone 8. Every other platform has NFC, too bad Apple skipped it.
- 09-13-2012, 08:23 AM #20
- 09-13-2012, 08:41 AM #21
Apple has never been known to jump on a new tech just because of hype...NFC just isn't solid enough yet, and when it is, you can rest assured Apple will polish up their NFC option on the iPhone and offer it to it's consumer base. Hell, it took them a while to get into the MMS world, and that was quite solidified when they finally offered it on the 3G.
Let's be honest here, while you might find NFC a really cool feature, anyone that isn't purely bullish*ting can admit that the technology is barely in the crawling state right now.
- 09-13-2012, 09:20 AM #22
- 09-13-2012, 09:22 AM #23
- 09-13-2012, 09:28 AM #24
They talked about it months ago.
Not sure how ready they are as I have read that HID's normal sensor is not the same as NFC but they are moving to make them compatible.
Either way I can't wait.
I haven't used NFC much and have had it for 1 year. I would love for my phone to have a credit card on just as a back up.
Imagine forgetting your wallet and you need fuel in your vehicle really bad. All the retail fuel dispensers that I use have the technology.
- 09-13-2012, 09:29 AM #25
NFC is EXACTLY the same...this is a convenience factor for many people, who wouldn't want to enjoy buying a coke at a machine without the need for exact change or carrying around cash (i personally never carry cash anymore, and can't remember the last time i bought a soda from a machine because of such). I'm really excited about the idea of being able to cut down on the need to have so many things connected to my bank, i have a debit card, a bank credit card, a check book in case a place doesn't take credit cards, etc etc etc...how nice to be able to stream line everything into such an easy place as a phone that you pretty much have on you 24 hours a day.
That said...the tech is new, unpolished and NOT wide spread...it's getting there, but it's simply not there yet. Next year, it'll be significantly improved. To the point of a need for it on all devices? Maybe, i would have said the same thing last year when the 4S was released...but it just didn't progress as fast as one would have thought (i think primarily because of security features). Next year? Here's hoping.