Hello, I have a white iPhone 4s, and I've had every case you could think of. I have always liked the newer otterbox defenders, but I was on eBay recently and saw a fake otterbox defender but in the older style, with the smaller flash diffuser ring, and I ordered it, it was about 12 dollars. I wanted to see if I'd like that style. And for a fake, I fell In love with it. It was really loose but I loved the way it looked. So I have to ask, are the older ones the same durability as the newer ones? I have 3 of the new 4s versions and ive had the same problem with all of them. The top left corner becomes really loose and doesn't fit around then plastic. Yesterday I ordered then white on black version of the older otterbox and I'm just wondering if it's the same durability? Hope to hear back soon! Have a nice day everyone