If I were a 'Blue Collar' guy (like my wife's cousin, who owns a roofing company) I would be all about the OtterBox...
But I dwell in a cubicle, so I am extremely happy with my Incase Pro Slider. Great form, great feel, great color (a Navy Blue mettalic-ish color) and even comes with a little stand to put it on while I Podcast in said cubicle