View Poll Results: Do you use a bluetooth headset regularly for phone calls or listening to music?
- 110. You may not vote on this poll
Yes, when possible.
No, it is uncomfortable.
No, it makes me look silly.
No, sound quality is not good.
No, too expensive.
No, for another reason or multiple reasons listed above (clarify in your post)
Do you use a bluetooth headset?
So the title says it all. Do you use a bluetooth headset for the iPhone? Either for phone calls or for listening to music?
If so, what model/brand do you use, and why?
I have a number of different brands, but I have never used one regularly because I can't find one that fits very well AND has great sound. They usually make my ears sore after a while. Of course, I am not spending $50 or more on them either - if I did I might find one that solves both of those problems. I just can't see spending $50 or more for a headset when I can just use headphones or put the phone against my ear.
I also forget to charge it, so the few cheap ones I have are all dead.
Last edited by cjvitek; 08-12-2009 at 10:58 PM.
- 08-12-2009, 11:12 PM #2
- 08-13-2009, 12:12 AM #3
i have never used on, or desired to. i could see the convenience if you took a lot of phone calls in a day; but i still make fun of the losers who walk around in wal-mart with their bluetooth. it's like a modern-day earring -- you're more "fresh" if you have a jawbone than a diamond stud. haha.
- 08-13-2009, 12:17 AM #4
I answered no b/c I never use one for regular use or listening to music most of the time, but I do use a stereo bluetooth headset when I run. I have the Moto S9-HDs. It's nice with the 3.1 voice control over bluetooth b/c I can press a button on the headset and say, "next track" or whatever. My only issue is voice control doesn't work when using Nike+.
- 08-13-2009, 12:30 AM #5
I prefer talking on my Bluetooth headset. I hate holdint the phone up to my ear. So I have my headset on almost all day every day.
I use the Bang Olufson earset 2. It looks big but it is sooo comfortable and the sound is better than my phones speaker. it is also very secure. No matter what I do it absolutely will not fall off. I have owned this headset for nearly two years and it is still working perfectly and does not look any worse for the wear.
@OP. You generally get what you pay for.
Last edited by chobbs1; 08-13-2009 at 12:33 AM.
- 08-13-2009, 05:57 AM #6
I'm with chobbs. I love having my hands free and not being tied to holding the phone to my head. I almost always use a bluetooth headset, and I use the Jabra 8030 stereo earbud.
Do I walk around WalMart looking affected? No. Do I get chores done at home while my iPhone is sitting on my desk charging? Absolutely! And if I'm stuck in a long line at the DMV or in the doctor's office, the same earbud will allow me to listen to my favorite podcasts, music, or a movie.
- 08-13-2009, 07:13 AM #7
- 08-13-2009, 07:27 AM #8
- 08-13-2009, 07:43 AM #9
I use one almost exclusively. Of course I drive and talk on the phone. A Lot! The life of a Salesman. I have gotten so use to it over the years that I use almost exclusively to talk on the phone. In the office, the yard, etc. Almost feels weird now to hold the phone up to my ear.
I use the Jabra JX10II. It is small, light , and lots of cool accessories for charging. It is starting to show it's age though and the "noise reduction" is not that great. Sound quality is excellent though. I will probably upgrade to the Jawbone 2 soon.
I use a wired headset to listen to music. May have to look into the BT ones.
Slightly [OT] I totally agree with the law that requires using a Headset (wired or BT) while driving. As someone who does this for a living, a headset is a MUST. If you drive and text/email while driving, you're an *****! What I do NOT agree with is the notion of banning ALL use of cell Phones while driving. This is just an example of the PC police taking a good idea and screwing it up! Sorry. Back off soap box. Continue the discussion.
- 08-13-2009, 07:56 AM #10
- 08-13-2009, 08:21 AM #11
Now, how that compares to eating a burger or something - I am not sure. I don't know if anyone has done that research. And as I said on the podcast, there are things that are more distracting than a phone call as well.
- 08-13-2009, 10:10 AM #13
In the car, I prefer a really good hands free. I've received compliments on the sound quality of the Blueant supertooth II for several years. I own a Scala 500 earpiece that works quite well. I bought a Blueant Z9i earpiece for its incredibly enhanced background sound suppression. speaking in a noisy room, callers cannot determine where I am. With the Z9i, I get a better fit using an eargel from an old Jabra. Based on ads on eBay, apparently others feel the same way as I see ads for eargels from Plantronics earpieces offered as compatible.
- 08-13-2009, 01:14 PM #14
Anyway, I hope you tell that I am being silly. Again, I totally support the use of headsets while driving. I know for a fact, from 12 years of personal experience, that driving while holding a phone to your ear is very distracting. The headsets free your hands up to stay on the wheel and allow much better range of motion for your head and vision. I also think that you should use Voice Dialing as much as possible. In my experience, people are distracted the most while dialing a number and driving.
I just think that outlawing the use of all cell phones in the car is going too far. Many people in this country would be severely handicapped in their jobs if they could not conduct business while driving to the next appointment/ job. Not all of us are politicians who can afford to have the tax payers pay for some one to chauffeur us around while they talk on the phone.
Talking on a phone causes more of a distraction than talking to someone in the car.
Anyway, I hope you tell that I am being silly.
Again, I totally support the use of headsets while driving. I know for a fact, from 12 years of personal experience, that driving while holding a phone to your ear is very distracting. The headsets free your hands up to stay on the wheel and allow much better range of motion for your head and vision. I also think that you should use Voice Dialing as much as possible. In my experience, people are distracted the most while dialing a number and driving.
Last edited by cjvitek; 08-13-2009 at 05:52 PM.
- 08-13-2009, 03:12 PM #16
A number of papers have been published in the Journal of Experimental Psychology. I can't reprint them here, (copyright reasons) but I can summarize a couple of them.
Drews et al in 2008 compared a person on the phone, a person talking to a passenger, and a person not talking. Cell phones resulted in more driving errors (interestingly, when talking to a passenger, the conversation often would involve aspects of what the driver was doing).
Horrey and Wickens (2006) showed no difference between passengers and cell phones (either hands free or hand held). This was a meta-analysis however, and as such the results may be questionable. (combining several results which may not have the same parameters, many times the authors didn't even get the data themselves). Caird et al (2008) did a similar meta analysis with similar results, but again, not their own data.
Charlton (2009) compared cell phone use, in car passenger, and out of car passenger (ie, walkie talking or something, but the passenger could see the car). Cell phone and remote passenger was worse than no conversation (duh) and in car passenger. Interestingly, he noted that with in car conversation, the passenger may slow the conversation when approaching a hazard or even warn the driver themselves (which did not happen with the cell phone conversations and only happened very little in the remote conversations). He suggested that conversation modulation was the key to why talking with a passenger was not as bad.
Amado and Ulupinar (2005) looked simply at reaction to visual cues (color and location) comparing simulated cell phone use and talking to a passenger, and found that cell phone use resulted in greater "distraction".
Strayer et al (2003) compared hands free and cell phones and found no difference, and speculated that it had to do with memory and visual recognition of driving cues.
Those are just a few that I found quickly.
- 08-13-2009, 05:57 PM #18
- 08-13-2009, 07:58 PM #19
- 08-13-2009, 09:15 PM #20
- 08-14-2009, 06:51 AM #21
- 08-14-2009, 08:14 AM #22
Two headsets, and why I use them.
I have two (one's actually intended for my wife's use in the car), and I'll continue to use them for two reasons:
1. The volume on my iPhone speaker is deplorable, EVEN after adjusting the "85%" setting in the phone's subsystem. Any headset beats the required mashing of my ears to clearly hear a caller while in the car or outside.
2. Convenience and safety. If I'm driving a distance, the headset is on the dash. Why on the dash? Because it takes me three seconds to see the call incoming (headset flashing), press the answer key, and stick it in my ear. I'm floored at how many people gripe about the discomfort while never removing the thing. I never wear a headset unless I'm on a call (with one exception--I'll get to that). Shove a pencil up your nose and see if it bothers you after hours on end; no matter how cushy, it will. Solution? remove the pencil, unless it's serving a purpose there.
The exception: If it's impossible or impractical to remove the headset, I leave it in. Two examples:
1. I wear a headset while on long rides (bicycle). I ride to work, on errands, and for leisure, sometimes for hours at a time. My wife and mother both have sensitive medical conditions, and I never trust the weather enough to keep my phone handy. Phone in saddle bag, headset on head. I answer every call, and IMMEDIATELY establish that I'm in the saddle and, unless it's life-or-death, cannot talk. The last thing I want to see on the road is some jackass screaming over the wind into his headset while he plows into my rear tire, so if I need to talk I'll pull off and finish up.
2. I'll occasionally headset up if I'm getting dirty and expecting a call. Planting in the garden, servicing the bicycle, doing dishes--one press with the back of the hand, and I'm on the call. No soapy / gritty / greasy iPhone.
On to the goods: I believe in thrift. As such, both of the headsets we own were bargains. One moreso, and the quality shows for the price:
Jabra BT2010. It's small, capable, and matches the phone. Noise cancellation is s-so, BUT it has one major advantage: it charges via USB-micro! So, anywhere my phone can be charged, so too can the headset. Work computer? Check. Apple wall wart? Check. Belkin USB iPhone charger for car? Check. Fit's fine, though it took me a couple of tries to realize it's intended for the right ear, meaning a swap to the left leaves the volume buttons inverted. Up is down, and so on. $7 shipped--a price that makes me less nervous when tossing it into my bag for the day.
The Plantronics Explorer 350 is our car-based headset, and it's quite nice. I found it on Amazon for cheap, and do like it. Solid build quality, with good noise cancellation, and nice specs (though some aren't iPhone-friendly until 3.1 3GS). I reviewed it on Amazon, if you're looking for more in-depth. $25 shipped.
Until my iPhone's 50% louder, or I quit driving alltogether, I'll be using a headset.
- 08-14-2009, 09:06 AM #23
- 08-14-2009, 09:30 AM #24
- 08-14-2009, 10:52 AM #25